Pitcher's Nightmare #405 2023 Topps Baseball — Card Value
2023 Topps BaseballWhat the Pitcher's Nightmare #405 (2023 Topps Baseball) card is worth — ungraded vs graded.
Pitcher's Nightmare #405 2023 Topps Baseball value — Ungraded $1 · Grade 9 $11 · PSA 10 $14. Prices updated June 2026.
Real sold prices per grade — the PSA 10 premium on this card is 14.0× raw.
Live on eBay right now
Which version do you have?
If budget is the primary concern, grab the Vintage Stock or Father's Day Blue for only $7. The premium versions like Golden Mirror SSP or Memorial Day Camo offer significant scarcity and collectibility, justifying their $30-$35 price tag. Casual fans should stick to the cheaper foils, while serious collectors aiming for high-end investment should target the top-tier, limited releases.
▍
Price data verified against · 1
Item details
- Brand
- Baseball
- Set
- 2023 Topps Baseball
- Sport
- Baseball
- Number
- #405
Pitcher's Nightmare #405 2023 Topps Baseball value
A raw (ungraded) Pitcher's Nightmare #405 runs around $1, a Grade 9 about $11, and a PSA 10 commands $14.
What drives the price
Grade, centering, rookie/star status, set scarcity, and print run drive sports-card value. PSA/BGS gem-mint copies and rookies of stars carry the biggest premiums; raw commons sell for little.
Price guide
Sold values by grade vs. what sellers ask today
| Condition | Value | Based on |
|---|---|---|
| Ungraded | $1 | eBay sold comps |
| Grade 9 | $11 | eBay sold comps |
| PSA 10 | $14 | eBay sold comps |
Frequently asked questions
- What is the starting resale value for this card?
- The ungraded version of Pitcher's Nightmare #405 is currently valued starting at $1.
- How much is a PSA 10 copy worth?
- A graded PSA 10 copy of this 2023 Topps Baseball card sells for $14.
- Is the value difference between ungraded and graded significant?
- Yes, the difference is substantial, with a PSA 10 valued at $14 compared to an ungraded copy starting at $1.
![Pitcher's Nightmare [Black] #405 2023 Topps Baseball](/api/images/junkpal-products/sports/pitcher-s-nightmare-black-405-baseball-cards-2023-topps-sport/thumb.webp)
![Pitcher's Nightmare [Purple] #405 2023 Topps Baseball](/api/images/junkpal-products/sports/pitcher-s-nightmare-purple-405-baseball-cards-2023-topps-sport/thumb.webp)
![Pitcher's Nightmare [Royal Blue] #405 2023 Topps Baseball](/api/images/junkpal-products/sports/pitcher-s-nightmare-royal-blue-405-baseball-cards-2023-topps-sport/thumb.webp)
![Pitcher's Nightmare [Vintage Stock] #405 2023 Topps Baseball](/api/images/junkpal-products/sports/pitcher-s-nightmare-vintage-stock-405-baseball-cards-2023-topps-sport/thumb.webp)
![Pitcher's Nightmare [Orange Foil] #405 2023 Topps Baseball](/api/images/junkpal-products/sports/pitcher-s-nightmare-orange-foil-405-baseball-cards-2023-topps-sport/thumb.webp)
![Pitcher's Nightmare [Red Foil] #405 2023 Topps Baseball](/api/images/junkpal-products/sports/pitcher-s-nightmare-red-foil-405-baseball-cards-2023-topps-sport/thumb.webp)
![Pitcher's Nightmare [Blue Foil] #405 2023 Topps Baseball](/api/images/junkpal-products/sports/pitcher-s-nightmare-blue-foil-405-baseball-cards-2023-topps-sport/thumb.webp)
![Pitcher's Nightmare [Green Foil] #405 2023 Topps Baseball](/api/images/junkpal-products/sports/pitcher-s-nightmare-green-foil-405-baseball-cards-2023-topps-sport/thumb.webp)