James Shields [Black] #541 2016 Topps Baseball — Card Value

Which version do you have?

For the absolute cheapest ownership, grab the Standard version at only $1. The premium versions like Black ($9) or Negative ($3) offer slight variations or different printing, but in this case, the value difference is minimal. If you only want the card, save your money on the Standard. Only pay more for the Black or Negative if you specifically want that aesthetic difference or a slightly higher perceived value.