What is the starting price for an ungraded Bill Tuttle #23?

The ungraded version of the Bill Tuttle #23 from the 1958 Topps Baseball set is listed at $15.

How much is a PSA 10 graded version worth?

A PSA 10 graded example of this card sells for $2895.

Is the 1958 Topps Baseball set rare?

This card is part of the 1958 Topps Baseball set, with values ranging from $15 (ungraded) to $2895 (PSA 10).

Bill Tuttle [Yellow] #23 1958 Topps Baseball — Card Value

Name: Bill Tuttle [Yellow] #23 1958 Topps Baseball — Card Value
Brand: Baseball

1958 Topps Baseball

What the Bill Tuttle [Yellow] #23 (1958 Topps Baseball) card is worth — ungraded vs graded.

Bill Tuttle [Yellow] #23 1958 Topps Baseball value — Ungraded $15 · Grade 9 $440 · PSA 10 $2,895. Prices updated July 2026.

Set · 1958 Topps BaseballNumber · #23

Live on eBay now

See current eBay listings

Value by grade

$15

Ungraded

29.3×

$440

Grade 9

193.0×

$2,895

PSA 10

Real sold prices per grade — the PSA 10 premium on this card is 193.0× raw.

Live on eBay right now

Which version do you have?

For the cheapest way to own it, grab the White version for $3. The Yellow version at $15 offers a slight premium, likely due to its color variation or perceived desirability, though scarcity isn't explicitly stated. Buyers prioritizing budget should stick with the White. Those willing to pay the extra for the Yellow are seeking a more visually distinct or slightly more collectible piece.

VersionUsedNewBuy

Yellow— this pageBill Tuttle [Yellow] #23 1958 Topps Baseball — Card Value$15.25$2,895eBay ↗

WhiteBill Tuttle [White] #23 1958 Topps Baseball — Card Value$2.66$1,267eBay ↗

JunkPal AI· resale insightanalyzing sold comps…

▍

Price data verified against · 1

SportsCardsPro — Bill Tuttle [Yellow] #23 1958 Topps Baseball$15.25

Item details

Brand: Baseball
Set: 1958 Topps Baseball
Sport: Baseball
Number: #23

Bill Tuttle [Yellow] #23 1958 Topps Baseball value

A raw (ungraded) Bill Tuttle [Yellow] #23 runs around $15, a Grade 9 about $440, and a PSA 10 commands $2895.

What drives the price

Grade, centering, rookie/star status, set scarcity, and print run drive sports-card value. PSA/BGS gem-mint copies and rookies of stars carry the biggest premiums; raw commons sell for little.

Price guide

Sold values by grade vs. what sellers ask today

Shop this on eBay ↗

Condition	Value	Based on
Ungraded	$15	eBay sold comps
Grade 9	$440	eBay sold comps
PSA 10	$2,895	eBay sold comps

Frequently asked questions

What is the starting price for an ungraded Bill Tuttle #23?: The ungraded version of the Bill Tuttle #23 from the 1958 Topps Baseball set is listed at $15.
How much is a PSA 10 graded version worth?: A PSA 10 graded example of this card sells for $2895.
Is the 1958 Topps Baseball set rare?: This card is part of the 1958 Topps Baseball set, with values ranging from $15 (ungraded) to $2895 (PSA 10).