Nightmare — Magic 4th Edition Card Value
Magic 4th EditionWhat the Nightmare card from Magic 4th Edition is worth — ungraded and graded (PSA 10).
Nightmare value — Ungraded $2 · Grade 9 $74. Prices updated July 2026.
Real sold prices per grade — the Grade 9 premium on this card is 37.0× raw.
Monthly CIB value, based on sold comps.
See the actual sold listings on eBay ↗Live on eBay right now
Which version do you have?
If you just want the Nightmare, buy the Standard version for only $2. The Alternate version at $51 offers a different edition, which is the premium upgrade. Collectors prioritizing display or collectibility should pay the extra for the Alternate. Buyers on a tighter budget should stick to the Standard version to own the item affordably.
▍
Price data verified against · 1
Item details
- Brand
- Magic
- Set
- Magic 4th Edition
- Game
- Magic
Nightmare (Magic 4th Edition) card value
An ungraded Nightmare from Magic 4th Edition averages around $2. A Grade 9 copy runs about $74, and a PSA 10 gem-mint commands null.
What drives the price
Centering, corners, edges, and surface decide a card's grade — and the grade decides the price. The jump from raw to PSA 10 can be 5–20×, so condition is everything. Holos, first editions, and shadowless prints carry the biggest premiums.
Price guide
Sold values by grade vs. what sellers ask today
| Condition | Value | Based on |
|---|---|---|
| Ungraded | $2 | eBay sold comps |
| Grade 9 | $74 | eBay sold comps |
Frequently asked questions
- What is the current resale value of Nightmare in Magic 4th Edition?
- An ungraded copy is available, while a Grade 9 copy of Nightmare is valued at $74.
- Is the condition of Nightmare important for its resale price?
- Yes, the condition significantly impacts the value, with a Grade 9 copy being priced at $74.
- What set does this version of Nightmare belong to?
- This version of Nightmare is from the Magic 4th Edition set.
![Nightmare [Alternate]](/api/images/junkpal-products/cards/nightmare-alternate-magic-4th-edition-card/img0/thumb.webp)
