What is the starting resale price for this Don Mattingly card?

The ungraded version of the Don Mattingly #856 from the 1991 Score Baseball set starts at $2.

How much is a PSA 10 graded version worth?

A PSA 10 graded copy of this 1991 Score Baseball card is currently valued at $53.

Is the ungraded condition still a good buy?

Yes, the ungraded card is available for $2, providing an entry point into this 1991 Score Baseball collectible.

Don Mattingly #856 1991 Score Baseball — Card Value

Name: Don Mattingly #856 1991 Score Baseball — Card Value
Brand: Baseball

1991 Score Baseball

What the Don Mattingly #856 (1991 Score Baseball) card is worth — ungraded vs graded.

Don Mattingly #856 1991 Score Baseball value — Ungraded $2 · Grade 9 $12 · PSA 10 $53. Prices updated June 2026.

Set · 1991 Score BaseballNumber · #856

Live on eBay now

See current eBay listings

Value by grade

Ungraded

6.0×

$12

Grade 9

26.5×

$53

PSA 10

Real sold prices per grade — the PSA 10 premium on this card is 26.5× raw.

Live on eBay right now

JunkPal AI· resale insightanalyzing sold comps…

▍

Price data verified against · 1

SportsCardsPro — Don Mattingly #856 1991 Score Baseball$1.59

Item details

Brand: Baseball
Set: 1991 Score Baseball
Sport: Baseball
Number: #856

Don Mattingly #856 1991 Score Baseball value

A raw (ungraded) Don Mattingly #856 runs around $2, a Grade 9 about $12, and a PSA 10 commands $53.

What drives the price

Grade, centering, rookie/star status, set scarcity, and print run drive sports-card value. PSA/BGS gem-mint copies and rookies of stars carry the biggest premiums; raw commons sell for little.

Price guide

Sold values by grade vs. what sellers ask today

Shop this on eBay ↗

Condition	Value	Based on
Ungraded	$2	eBay sold comps
Grade 9	$12	eBay sold comps
PSA 10	$53	eBay sold comps

Frequently asked questions

What is the starting resale price for this Don Mattingly card?: The ungraded version of the Don Mattingly #856 from the 1991 Score Baseball set starts at $2.
How much is a PSA 10 graded version worth?: A PSA 10 graded copy of this 1991 Score Baseball card is currently valued at $53.
Is the ungraded condition still a good buy?: Yes, the ungraded card is available for $2, providing an entry point into this 1991 Score Baseball collectible.