What is the current resale value for an ungraded Make a Wish [Foil]?

The resale value is determined by its ungraded condition within the Magic Innistrad set.

Is the foil finish important for the value of this card?

Yes, the foil finish is a key characteristic of this specific Make a Wish card.

Where can I find this Magic Innistrad card?

You can find this card listed on JunkPal, a marketplace for Magic items.

Make a Wish [Foil] — Magic Innistrad Card Value

Name: Make a Wish [Foil] — Magic Innistrad Card Value
Brand: Magic

Magic Innistrad

What the Make a Wish [Foil] card from Magic Innistrad is worth — ungraded and graded (PSA 10).

Make a Wish [Foil] value — Ungraded $1. Prices updated July 2026.

Set · Magic InnistradGame · Magic

Live on eBay now

↘ Falling · -50%

See current eBay listings

Complete-in-box price history

Monthly CIB value, based on sold comps.

See the actual sold listings on eBay ↗

Live on eBay right now

Which version do you have?

To simply own Make a Wish, buy the Standard version for $0. The Foil version, priced at $1, offers a minor aesthetic upgrade, likely just a different finish, not significant scarcity or edition change. If your goal is pure ownership without investment, stick to the Standard. Only pay the extra dollar for the Foil if you specifically want the visual difference.

VersionUsedNewBuy

Foil— this pageMake a Wish [Foil] — Magic Innistrad Card Value$0.55—eBay ↗

StandardMake a Wish — Magic Innistrad Card Value$0.06—eBay ↗

JunkPal AI· resale insightanalyzing sold comps…

▍

Price data verified against · 1

PriceCharting — Make a Wish [Foil] (Magic Innistrad)$0.55

Item details

Brand: Magic
Set: Magic Innistrad
Game: Magic

Make a Wish [Foil] (Magic Innistrad) card value

An ungraded Make a Wish [Foil] from Magic Innistrad averages around $1. A Grade 9 copy runs about null, and a PSA 10 gem-mint commands null.

What drives the price

Centering, corners, edges, and surface decide a card's grade — and the grade decides the price. The jump from raw to PSA 10 can be 5–20×, so condition is everything. Holos, first editions, and shadowless prints carry the biggest premiums.

Price guide

What this actually trades for — sold values by condition vs. what sellers are asking today

Shop this on eBay ↗

Condition	Value	Based on
Ungraded	$1	eBay sold comps

Frequently asked questions

What is the current resale value for an ungraded Make a Wish [Foil]?: The resale value is determined by its ungraded condition within the Magic Innistrad set.
Is the foil finish important for the value of this card?: Yes, the foil finish is a key characteristic of this specific Make a Wish card.
Where can I find this Magic Innistrad card?: You can find this card listed on JunkPal, a marketplace for Magic items.