Journey into Mystery #51 (1959) — Comic Book Value
Journey Into MysteryWhat Journey into Mystery #51 (1959) is worth — ungraded and CGC graded (6.0, 8.0).
Journey into Mystery #51 (1959) value — Ungraded $136 · Grade 6.0 $377 · Grade 8.0 $2,211. Prices updated September 2026.
Real sold prices per grade — the Grade 8.0 premium on this card is 16.3× raw.
Live on eBay right now
updated Sep 12Asking prices of these 12 listings: median $275.00 · mean $405.10 · range $2.99–$1,995.00
JOURNEY INTO MYSTERY #51 CGC 4.5 LT/OW PAGES // ATLAS COMICS 1959Top RatedMakes offers100%★$230.00+$15.00Buy ↗
Journey into Mystery #51 (1959) CGC 4.0 VG OW/White Atlas Robot on Rampage RAREMakes offers100%★$275.00Buy ↗
Journey into Mystery #51 (1959) CGC 7.5 VF- C/OW Atlas Robot on Rampage RARE PCMakes offers100%★$1,995.00Buy ↗
Journey Into Mystery #51 Photocopy Comic Book99.9%★$10.00Buy ↗
Journey into Mystery #51 GD 2.0 1959Top RatedMakes offers100%★$300.00+$7.00Buy ↗
Journey into Mystery # 51 Marvel (1959) VG100%★$199.99+$11.00Buy ↗
Journey into Mystery Robot Cover (pre Marvel) #51 CGC 3.5 Jack Kirby Steve DitkoMakes offers100%★$349.99+$9.99Buy ↗
Journey into Mystery Vol 1 51 VG+ (4.5) Marvel (1959)99.8%★$198.26+$12.98Buy ↗
Journey Into Mystery #51 CGC 6.5 White Pgs Pre-Thor Atlas Kirby Ditko Wood Art!Makes offers100%★$595.00Buy ↗
Journey into Mystery #51 CGC 4.5 1959 4297783003Top Rated100%★$530.00+$7.00Buy ↗
Journey Into Fear #3 CGC 3.0 Black Cat GGA Creepy Cover 1951 Superior PCHMakes offers100%★$175.00Buy ↗
Thor #51 1998 Silver Age Skybox Marvel Journey Into Mystery #119 coverTop RatedFree shipMakes offers100%★$2.99free shipLowestJunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links.
▍
Price data verified against · 1
Item details
- Series
- Journey Into Mystery
Journey into Mystery #51 (1959) comic value
An ungraded copy of Journey into Mystery #51 (1959) averages around $136. A CGC 6.0 runs about $377, and a CGC 8.0 commands $2211.
What drives the price
Grade is everything in comics — spine ticks, page color, and restoration decide the number, and the jump from raw to high grade can be 10×+. Key issues (first appearances, origins, deaths) carry the biggest premiums, and early printings beat reprints.
Price guide
Sold values by grade vs. what sellers ask today
| Condition | Value | Based on |
|---|---|---|
| Ungraded | $136 | eBay sold comps |
| Grade 6.0 | $377 | eBay sold comps |
| Grade 8.0 | $2,211 | eBay sold comps |
| Live asking — low / typical / high | $2.99 / $275 / $1,995 | 20 live eBay listings ↗ |
Market check: As of September 12, 2026, 20 live eBay listings ask $2.99–$1,995.00 (median $275.00).
Frequently asked questions
- What is the approximate value of an ungraded copy?
- An ungraded copy of Journey Into Mystery #51 is currently valued around $64.
- How much does a Grade 8.0 sell for?
- A high-grade copy, specifically a Grade 8.0, has been listed for $2211.
- Is the difference between ungraded and graded worth the investment?
- Yes, the difference is substantial; a Grade 6.0 sells for $311 compared to the ungraded price.