What is the current market price for a non-foil Chthonian Nightmare?

The non-foil version of Chthonian Nightmare from Modern Horizons 3 is currently listed at $2.02.

Is the foil version significantly more valuable?

Yes, the foil version of this Rare card is valued higher at $4.33.

What set does Chthonian Nightmare belong to?

Chthonian Nightmare is a Rare card found in the Modern Horizons 3 set (#406).

Chthonian Nightmare (Modern Horizons 3) — MTG Card Value

Name: Chthonian Nightmare (Modern Horizons 3) — MTG Card Value
Brand: Rare

Modern Horizons 3

What the Chthonian Nightmare from Modern Horizons 3 is worth — market price for the single.

Chthonian Nightmare (Modern Horizons 3) value — Market $1.75 · Foil $4.79. Prices updated August 2026.

Set · Modern Horizons 3Rarity · RareNumber · #406

Live on eBay now

See current eBay listings

Live on eBay right now

Which version do you have?

If you just want the card, buy the Standard: $1 version for the cheapest entry. The higher priced Standard: $2 and Standard: $6 versions offer no tangible benefit in this case, as they are all the same card from the same set. Therefore, save your money and purchase the lowest priced Standard: $1 version unless you have a specific reason to acquire a higher-priced copy.

VersionUsedNewBuy

StandardChthonian Nightmare (Modern Horizons 3) — MTG Card Value$5.66$11.26eBay ↗

Standard— this pageChthonian Nightmare (Modern Horizons 3) — MTG Card Value$1.7$4.67eBay ↗

StandardChthonian Nightmare (Modern Horizons 3) — MTG Card Value$0.56$0.67eBay ↗

JunkPal AI· resale insightanalyzing sold comps…

▍

Price data verified against · 1

Scryfall — Chthonian Nightmare (Modern Horizons 3)$1.75

Item details

Brand: Rare
Set: Modern Horizons 3
Rarity: Rare
Number: #406

Chthonian Nightmare (Modern Horizons 3) value

The Chthonian Nightmare from Modern Horizons 3 (#406) has a market price of $1.75, with the foil at $4.79.

What drives the price

For Magic singles, set, rarity, condition (NM vs played), and playability/format demand drive value. First printings, foils, and cards that see competitive or Commander play hold value best; reprints soften prices.

Price guide

What this actually trades for — sold values by condition vs. what sellers are asking today

Shop this on eBay ↗

Condition	Value	Based on
Market	$1.75	eBay sold comps
Foil	$4.79	eBay sold comps

Frequently asked questions

What is the current market price for a non-foil Chthonian Nightmare?: The non-foil version of Chthonian Nightmare from Modern Horizons 3 is currently listed at $2.02.
Is the foil version significantly more valuable?: Yes, the foil version of this Rare card is valued higher at $4.33.
What set does Chthonian Nightmare belong to?: Chthonian Nightmare is a Rare card found in the Modern Horizons 3 set (#406).