Magic Innistrad resale values

548 Magic Innistrad priced on real sold comps, ranging from $0 to $350. See what each is worth — loose or complete — before you buy or sell.

Updated September 2026 · prices refresh as new sales close.

Caravan Vigil [Foil]$2 ungraded

Dead Weight$0 ungraded

Curiosity$1 ungraded

Butcher's Cleaver [Foil]$1 ungraded

Chapel Geist$0 ungraded

Claustrophobia [Foil]$1 ungraded

Cloistered Youth$0 ungraded

Darkthicket Wolf [Foil]$0 ungraded

Cobbled Wings [Foil]$0 ungraded

Curse of the Pierced Heart$0 ungraded

Angel of Flight Alabaster$0 ungraded

Ambush Viper$0 ungraded

Blazing Torch [Foil]$0 ungraded

Abattoir Ghoul$0 ungraded

Avacyn's Pilgrim$1 ungraded

Abattoir Ghoul [Foil]$0 ungraded

Butcher's Cleaver$0 ungraded

Bitterheart Witch$0 ungraded

Back from the Brink$0 ungraded

Boneyard Wurm [Foil]$1 ungraded

Burning Vengeance$0 ungraded

Brimstone Volley [Foil]$1 ungraded

Ancient Grudge$0 ungraded

Ashmouth Hound$0 ungraded

Blazing Torch$0 ungraded

Forest #262$2 ungraded

Brain Weevil$0 ungraded

Bloodcrazed Neonate [Foil]$1 ungraded

Altar's Reap [Foil]$2 ungraded

Armored Skaab$0 ungraded

Angel of Flight Alabaster [Foil]$1 ungraded

Forest [Foil] #262$3 ungraded

Abbey Griffin [Foil]$1 ungraded

Forest #263$3 ungraded

Bonds of Faith$0 ungraded

Brain Weevil [Foil]$0 ungraded

Boneyard Wurm$0 ungraded

Avacynian Priest [Foil]$1 ungraded

Bramblecrush [Foil]$1 ungraded

Ancient Grudge [Foil]$1 ungraded

Bitterheart Witch [Foil]$0 ungraded

Burning Vengeance [Foil]$0 ungraded

Bloodcrazed Neonate$0 ungraded

Ashmouth Hound [Foil]$1 ungraded

Armored Skaab [Foil]$0 ungraded

Forest [Foil] #263$1 ungraded

Forest [Foil] #264$2 ungraded

Battleground Geist$0 ungraded

Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.