Magic Innistrad resale values

548 Magic Innistrad priced on real sold comps, ranging from $0 to $350. See what each is worth — loose or complete — before you buy or sell.

Updated September 2026 · prices refresh as new sales close.

Rebuke [Foil]$0 ungraded

Swamp$0 ungraded

Island [Foil] #255$2 ungraded

Mountain #259$2 ungraded

Runechanter's Pike$0 ungraded

Nephalia Drownyard$0 ungraded

Island #254$1 ungraded

Vampire [Token] #5$3 ungraded

Urgent Exorcism [Foil]$0 ungraded

Pitchburn Devils [Foil]$0 ungraded

Plains #251$2 ungraded

Midnight Haunting$0 ungraded

Mirror-Mad Phantasm$1 ungraded

Stony Silence$1 ungraded

Unburial Rites [Foil]$3 ungraded

Undead Alchemist$1 ungraded

Unbreathing Horde$0 ungraded

Ranger's Guile [Foil]$1 ungraded

Reckless Waif [Foil]$1 ungraded

Stromkirk Noble$1 ungraded

Slayer of the Wicked [Foil]$0 ungraded

Pitchburn Devils #156$0 ungraded

Plains [Foil] #251$2 ungraded

Traveler's Amulet [Foil]$0 ungraded

Mountain$0 ungraded

Morkrut Banshee$0 ungraded

Mountain #260$1 ungraded

Splinterfright [Foil]$1 ungraded

Moorland Haunt [Foil]$2 ungraded

Plains$9 ungraded

Swamp [Foil] #257$3 ungraded

Village Ironsmith [Foil]$1 ungraded

One-Eyed Scarecrow [Foil]$1 ungraded

Victim of Night [Foil]$4 ungraded

Nevermore [Foil]$4 ungraded

Stensia Bloodhall$0 ungraded

Morkrut Banshee [Foil]$0 ungraded

Island #255$0 ungraded

Mountain [Foil] #260$1 ungraded

Wolf [Token] #6$1 ungraded

Checklist [Token]$3 ungraded

Champion of the Parish$2 ungraded

Grizzled Outcasts [Foil]$0 ungraded

Claustrophobia$0 ungraded

Dearly Departed [Foil]$0 ungraded

Gruesome Deformity [Foil]$0 ungraded

Kessig Cagebreakers [Foil]$2 ungraded

Bump in the Night [Foil]$4 ungraded

Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.