Magic Innistrad resale values

548 Magic Innistrad priced on real sold comps, ranging from $0 to $350. See what each is worth — loose or complete — before you buy or sell.

Updated September 2026 · prices refresh as new sales close.

Gallows Warden [Foil]$1 ungraded

Doomed Traveler [Foil]$1 ungraded

Doomed Traveler$0 ungraded

Frightful Delusion$0 ungraded

Festerhide Boar [Foil]$0 ungraded

Devil's Play [Foil]$2 ungraded

Furor of the Bitten$0 ungraded

Elder of Laurels [Foil]$1 ungraded

Dissipate$0 ungraded

Essence of the Wild$1 ungraded

Elder Cathar [Foil]$0 ungraded

Elite Inquisitor [Foil]$1 ungraded

Falkenrath Marauders$0 ungraded

Full Moon's Rise$0 ungraded

Devil's Play$0 ungraded

Diregraf Ghoul$0 ungraded

Furor of the Bitten [Foil]$0 ungraded

Elder of Laurels$0 ungraded

Forbidden Alchemy [Foil]$0 ungraded

Elder Cathar$0 ungraded

Evil Twin$1 ungraded

Gatstaf Shepherd [Foil]$1 ungraded

Dream Twist [Foil]$1 ungraded

Gallows Warden$0 ungraded

Fortress Crab$0 ungraded

Desperate Ravings$0 ungraded

Dead Weight [Foil]$1 ungraded

Civilized Scholar$0 ungraded

Creeping Renaissance$1 ungraded

Charmbreaker Devils [Foil]$1 ungraded

Civilized Scholar [Foil]$0 ungraded

Chapel Geist [Foil]$0 ungraded

Curse of the Bloody Tome$0 ungraded

Curse of Death's Hold$1 ungraded

Curse of Oblivion [Foil]$2 ungraded

Creepy Doll$1 ungraded

Cellar Door [Foil]$1 ungraded

Curse of the Nightly Hunt [Foil]$0 ungraded

Cellar Door$0 ungraded

Demonmail Hauberk [Foil]$1 ungraded

Curse of Stalked Prey [Foil]$2 ungraded

Curse of the Nightly Hunt$0 ungraded

Curse of Oblivion$0 ungraded

Caravan Vigil$0 ungraded

Deranged Assistant$0 ungraded

Darkthicket Wolf$0 ungraded

Deranged Assistant [Foil]$1 ungraded

Crossway Vampire [Foil]$2 ungraded

Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.