Magic Innistrad resale values

548 Magic Innistrad priced on real sold comps, ranging from $0 to $350. See what each is worth — loose or complete — before you buy or sell.

Updated September 2026 · prices refresh as new sales close.

Paraselene [Foil]$2 ungraded

Sensory Deprivation$0 ungraded

Night Terrors$0 ungraded

Orchard Spirit [Foil]$0 ungraded

Rage Thrower [Foil]$0 ungraded

Paraselene$0 ungraded

Mausoleum Guard$0 ungraded

Ludevic's Test Subject [Foil]$1 ungraded

Maw of the Mire$0 ungraded

Manor Skeleton [Foil]$1 ungraded

Nevermore$1 ungraded

Nephalia Drownyard [Foil]$3 ungraded

Lumberknot [Foil]$1 ungraded

Moldgraf Monstrosity$0 ungraded

Lost in the Mist [Foil]$1 ungraded

Kruin Outlaw$0 ungraded

Ludevic's Test Subject$1 ungraded

Midnight Haunting [Foil]$1 ungraded

Moan of the Unhallowed$0 ungraded

Memory's Journey$0 ungraded

Make a Wish$0 ungraded

Mask of Avacyn$1 ungraded

Markov Patrician$0 ungraded

Murder of Crows$0 ungraded

Manor Gargoyle$0 ungraded

Maw of the Mire [Foil]$0 ungraded

Lantern Spirit [Foil]$1 ungraded

Moorland Haunt$1 ungraded

Makeshift Mauler [Foil]$0 ungraded

Make a Wish [Foil]$1 ungraded

Moan of the Unhallowed [Foil]$0 ungraded

Moment of Heroism [Foil]$0 ungraded

Mulch [Foil]$2 ungraded

Lumberknot$0 ungraded

Manor Skeleton$0 ungraded

Moonmist$2 ungraded

Lantern Spirit$0 ungraded

Murder of Crows [Foil]$0 ungraded

Moon Heron$0 ungraded

Mausoleum Guard [Foil]$1 ungraded

Manor Gargoyle [Foil]$1 ungraded

Moldgraf Monstrosity [Foil]$3 ungraded

Naturalize [Foil]$0 ungraded

Mindshrieker$1 ungraded

Gnaw to the Bone [Foil]$6 ungraded

Hysterical Blindness [Foil]$0 ungraded

Hanweir Watchkeep$0 ungraded

Geistflame [Foil]$1 ungraded

Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.