Magic Innistrad resale values

548 Magic Innistrad priced on real sold comps, ranging from $0 to $350. See what each is worth — loose or complete — before you buy or sell.

Updated August 2026 · prices refresh as new sales close.

Spidery Grasp [Foil]$1 used

Stensia Bloodhall [Foil]$1 used

Stromkirk Patrol$0 used

Stitcher's Apprentice$0 used

Think Twice$0 used

Sturmgeist$0 used

Spectral Rider [Foil]$1 used

Tormented Pariah$0 used

Skirsdag High Priest$1 used

Spirit [Token]$0 used

Spectral Rider$0 used

Sturmgeist [Foil]$1 used

Skaab Goliath [Foil]$0 used

Ranger's Guile$0 used

Sever the Bloodline [Foil]$1 used

Prey Upon [Foil]$0 used

Purify the Grave [Foil]$0 used

Orchard Spirit [Foil]$0 used

Scourge of Geier Reach [Foil]$0 used

Sharpened Pitchfork [Foil]$0 used

Rotting Fensnake [Foil]$0 used

Night Terrors [Foil]$1 used

Sensory Deprivation [Foil]$1 used

Shimmering Grotto [Foil]$1 used

Reckless Waif$0 used

Silver-Inlaid Dagger [Foil]$1 used

Runic Repetition [Foil]$1 used

Screeching Bat [Foil]$0 used

Selhoff Occultist [Foil]$0 used

Runic Repetition$0 used

Sensory Deprivation$0 used

One-Eyed Scarecrow$0 used

Rolling Temblor [Foil]$0 used

Night Revelers$0 used

Sever the Bloodline$0 used

Selfless Cathar [Foil]$0 used

Night Terrors$0 used

Silver-Inlaid Dagger$0 used

Rally the Peasants$0 used

Rakish Heir$0 used

Rage Thrower$0 used

Screeching Bat$0 used

Paraselene [Foil]$2 used

Silverchase Fox$0 used

Rotting Fensnake$0 used

Riot Devils [Foil]$1 used

Night Revelers [Foil]$0 used

Selhoff Occultist$0 used

Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.