Clefairy [Red Heart Error] #5 Value Guide 2026

About Clefairy [Red Heart Error] #5

Clefairy #5 from the Pokémon Base Set is a highly sought-after card, particularly when it features the rare Red Heart Error [5]. This iconic card was released as part of the 1999 Pokémon Base Set [4]. Players and collectors are drawn to this card not only for its status as a foundational piece of the Pokémon TCG but also because of the unique printing error [5, 6]. The Red Heart Error itself is a fascinating misprint, sometimes referred to as the "heart stamp" [2, 6], making it a significant piece of TCG history [3].

What it's worth right now

Currently, the market shows a notable difference between what sellers are asking and what the card has actually sold for. The median of the current eBay asking prices across 8 live listings is $2199.95. However, the real sold-comp value for this card is $415 used. This gap suggests that many listings are priced at a premium, likely reflecting high-grade, authenticated examples.

What drives the price

The value of the Clefairy [Red Heart Error] #5 is heavily influenced by several factors, chief among them being the card's condition and completeness. Graded examples command significantly higher prices, as seen in the sample listings which feature PSA or CGC grading [1]. The presence of the specific Red Heart Error is crucial, but the degree and quality of this error, as well as the overall centering and preservation of the card, play a massive role in determining its worth [2]. Ungraded examples, such as those listed for around $400, offer a different entry point compared to the high-end graded sales.

Buying and selling it

When considering buying or selling, it is important to compare the asking prices against the established sold median. If the current asks are substantially higher than the recent sold comps, patience may be warranted to secure a fair deal. For sellers, high-quality grading is often the key differentiator in achieving top-tier prices. When listing, be meticulous about accurately describing the condition and the specific nature of the error to attract the right buyers. For a comprehensive look at the historical performance of this card, you can review the full sold-comp history.

For the most up-to-date pricing and to view live listings, please check out our current selection below.