Magic Shadows Over Innistrad resale values

606 Magic Shadows Over Innistrad priced on real sold comps, ranging from $0 to $177. See what each is worth — loose or complete — before you buy or sell.

Updated August 2026 · prices refresh as new sales close.

Runaway Carriage [Foil]$0 used

Ooze [Token] #8$0 used

Clue [Token] #16$0 used

Island #287$0 used

Reduce to Ashes [Foil]$0 used

Graf Mole #207$0 used

Catalog [Foil]$0 used

Epitaph Golem [Foil]$0 used

Furtive Homunculus [Foil]$0 used

Shamble Back #134$0 used

Vampire Knight [Token] #4$0 used

Mad Prophet [Foil]$0 used

Gloomwidow [Foil]$0 used

Reduce to Ashes #176$0 used

Mad Prophet$0 used

Forest #297$0 used

Forest #295$1 used

Explosive Apparatus$0 used

Kindly Stranger #119$0 used

Inspiring Captain [Foil]$0 used

Moorland Drifter [Foil]$0 used

Stensia Masquerade #184$0 used

Silburlind Snapper$0 used

Apothecary Geist [Foil]$0 used

Town Gossipmonger [Foil] #46$0 used

To the Slaughter [Foil]$0 used

Furtive Homunculus #64$0 used

Warped Landscape [Foil]$1 used

Tenacity [Foil]$1 used

Tenacity #42$0 used

Engulf the Shore #58$1 used

Vessel of Nascency$0 used

Ulrich's Kindred$0 used

Ghostly Wings #066$0 used

Ulrich's Kindred [Foil]$1 used

Vessel of Paramnesia [Foil]$0 used

Vampire Noble [Foil]$0 used

Vessel of Malignity$0 used

Angelic Purge #3$0 used

Clue [Token] #14$1 used

Throttle$0 used

Stern Constable [Foil] #39$0 used

Thraben Gargoyle$0 used

Stormrider Spirit [Foil]$0 used

Voldaren Duelist$0 used

Veteran Cathar [Foil]$0 used

Tormenting Voice [Foil]$0 used

Stormrider Spirit$0 used

Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.