The Most Valuable Magic Shadows Over Innistrad Cards

Ranked by real closed-sale prices across 534 tracked Magic Shadows Over Innistrad items — not guesses, not asking prices. Updated August 2026; the order shifts as the market does. Right now the crown belongs to Booster Box at $177.37.

On a budget: under $20 · under $50 · under $100

1. 1
   
   Booster Box

   $177.37
   eBay ↗Sold comps →
2. 2
   
   Fat Pack

   $51.53
   eBay ↗Sold comps →
3. 3
   
   Eerie Interlude [Foil]

   $13.81
   eBay ↗Sold comps →
4. 4
   
   Relentless Dead [Foil]

   $12
   eBay ↗Sold comps →
5. 5
   
   Relentless Dead

   $10.52
   eBay ↗Sold comps →
6. 6
   
   Archangel Avacyn [Foil]

   $9.49
   eBay ↗Sold comps →
7. 7
   
   Sorin, Grim Nemesis [Foil]

   $8.96
   eBay ↗Sold comps →
8. 8
   
   Booster Pack

   $6.98
   eBay ↗Sold comps →
9. 9
   
   Essence Flux [Foil]

   $6.45
   eBay ↗Sold comps →
10. 10
    
    Diregraf Colossus [Foil]

    $6.36
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
11. 11
    
    Rattlechains [Prerelease] #81

    $6.27
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
12. 12
    
    Open the Armory [Foil]

    $6.2
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
13. 13
    
    Eerie Interlude

    $6.14
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
14. 14
    
    Tamiyo's Journal [Foil]

    $6.11
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
15. 15
    
    Cryptolith Rite

    $6
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
16. 16
    
    Anguished Unmaking [Foil]

    $5.69
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
17. 17
    
    Nahiri, the Harbinger [Foil]

    $5.36· $199.99 new/sealed
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
18. 18
    
    Alms of the Vein [Foil]

    $5.15
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
19. 19
    
    Cryptolith Rite [Foil]

    $5.06
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
20. 20
    
    Behind the Scenes [Foil]

    $5.06
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
21. 21
    
    Behold the Beyond [Foil]

    $4.97· $135 new/sealed
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
22. 22
    
    Westvale Abbey [Foil]

    $4.76
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
23. 23
    
    Diregraf Colossus #107

    $4.5
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
24. 24
    
    Fevered Visions [Foil]

    $4.33
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
25. 25
    
    Ulvenwald Hydra [Foil]

    $4.22
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
26. 26
    
    Sigarda, Heron's Grace [Foil]

    $4
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
27. 27
    
    Thalia's Lieutenant [Foil]

    $3.99
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
28. 28
    
    Westvale Abbey #281

    $3.97
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
29. 29
    
    Olivia, Mobilized for War [Foil]

    $3.96
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
30. 30
    
    Indulgent Aristocrat [Foil]

    $3.91
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
31. 31
    
    Seasons Past [Foil]

    $3.85
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
32. 32
    
    Engulf The Shore [Prerelease] #58

    $3.79
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
33. 33
    
    Archangel Avacyn #5

    $3.7
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
34. 34
    
    Odric, Lunarch Marshal [Foil]

    $3.69
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
35. 35
    
    Geier Reach Bandit [Foil]

    $3.44
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
36. 36
    
    Sorin, Grim Nemesis

    $3.41
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
37. 37
    
    Archangel Avacyn // Avacyn, the Purifier [Prerelease] #5

    $3.08
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
38. 38
    
    Sage of Ancient Lore [Foil]

    $3.07
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
39. 39
    
    Stensia Masquerade [Foil]

    $3.01
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
40. 40
    
    Open the Armory

    $2.88
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
41. 41
    
    Startled Awake [Foil]

    $2.87
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
42. 42
    
    Jace, Unraveler of Secrets [Foil] #69

    $2.73
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
43. 43
    
    Always Watching [Foil]

    $2.69
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
44. 44
    
    Pore Over the Pages [Foil]

    $2.63
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
45. 45
    
    The Gitrog Monster #245

    $2.49
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
46. 46
    
    Erdwal Illuminator [Foil]

    $2.49
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
47. 47
    
    Traverse the Ulvenwald [Foil]

    $2.45
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
48. 48
    
    Tamiyo's Journal

    $2.41
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
49. 49
    
    Trail of Evidence [Foil]

    $2.4
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
50. 50
    
    Hermit of the Natterknolls [Foil]

    $2.37
    eBay ↗Sold comps →

Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.