Magic Shadows Over Innistrad resale values

606 Magic Shadows Over Innistrad priced on real sold comps, ranging from $0 to $177. See what each is worth — loose or complete — before you buy or sell.

Updated August 2026 · prices refresh as new sales close.

Obsessive Skinner$0 used

Swamp #289$1 used

Crow of Dark Tidings [Foil]$0 used

Indulgent Aristocrat #118$0 used

Jace, Unraveler of Secrets [Foil] #69$3 used

Inspiring Captain$0 used

Drownyard Temple [Foil]$2 used

Falkenrath Gorger [Foil]$1 used

Bloodmad Vampire [Foil]$1 used

Compelling Deterrence [Foil]$1 used

Descend upon the Sinful [Foil]$2 used

Inner Struggle$0 used

Brain in a Jar [Foil]$2 used

Devils' Playground$0 used

Drownyard Explorers [Foil]$0 used

Magmatic Chasm$0 used

Trail of Evidence [Foil]$2 used

Confront the Unknown [Foil]$1 used

Falkenrath Gorger$0 used

Hinterland Logger [Foil]$0 used

Crawling Sensation [Foil]$2 used

Bound by Moonsilver [Foil]$0 used

Stensia Masquerade [Foil]$3 used

Fork in the Road [Foil]$1 used

Ghoulsteed [Foil]$0 used

The Gitrog Monster [Foil]$6 used

Plains #283$1 used

Topplegeist [Foil]$3 used

Devils' Playground [Foil]$0 used

Eerie Interlude$6 used

Forgotten Creation$0 used

Angelic Purge [Foil]$0 used

Biting Rain [Foil]$1 used

Dance with Devils [Foil]$0 used

Thornhide Wolves #232$0 used

Nahiri, the Harbinger$1 used

Forgotten Creation [Foil]$2 used

Call the Bloodline [Foil]$0 used

Essence Flux$2 used

Flameblade Angel [Foil Promo] #157$1 used

Drunau Corpse Trawler [Foil]$0 used

Engulf the Shore [Foil]$2 used

Second Harvest [Foil]$2 used

Archangel Avacyn // Avacyn, the Purifier [Prerelease] #5$3 used

Seasons Past [Foil]$4 used

Ethereal Guidance [Foil]$0 used

Heir of Falkenrath [Foil]$1 used

Clue [Token] #15$0 used

Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.