2016 Topps Baseball resale values

4,819 2016 Topps Baseball priced on real sold comps, ranging from $0 to $1,300. See what each is worth — loose or complete — before you buy or sell.

Updated September 2026 · prices refresh as new sales close.

James Shields #541 2016 Topps Baseball$1 ungraded

Curt Casali [Gold] #540 2016 Topps Baseball$0 ungraded

Tampa Bay Rays [Black] #537 2016 Topps Baseball$5 ungraded

James Shields [Vintage Stock] #541 2016 Topps Baseball$0 ungraded

Tampa Bay Rays [Purple] #537 2016 Topps Baseball$3 ungraded

Michael Reed [Black] #538 2016 Topps Baseball$12 ungraded

Tampa Bay Rays [Gold] #537 2016 Topps Baseball$2 ungraded

Scott Van Slyke [Negative] #542 2016 Topps Baseball$3 ungraded

Michael Reed [Rainbow Foil] #538 2016 Topps Baseball$0 ungraded

Scott Van Slyke [Black] #542 2016 Topps Baseball$6 ungraded

Tampa Bay Rays [Pink] #537 2016 Topps Baseball$3 ungraded

Nate Karns [Negative] #539 2016 Topps Baseball$3 ungraded

James Shields [Rainbow Foil] #541 2016 Topps Baseball$0 ungraded

Nate Karns [Rainbow Foil] #539 2016 Topps Baseball$0 ungraded

Scott Van Slyke [Purple] #542 2016 Topps Baseball$4 ungraded

Tampa Bay Rays [Rainbow Foil] #537 2016 Topps Baseball$0 ungraded

James Shields [Black] #541 2016 Topps Baseball$9 ungraded

Michael Reed [Negative] #538 2016 Topps Baseball$8 ungraded

Scott Van Slyke [#42 Jersey] #542 2016 Topps Baseball$3 ungraded

Nate Karns [Vintage Stock] #539 2016 Topps Baseball$4 ungraded

Scott Van Slyke #542 2016 Topps Baseball$4 ungraded

Carlos Rodon #543 2016 Topps Baseball$2 ungraded

Curt Casali [Clear] #540 2016 Topps Baseball$1 ungraded

Carlos Rodon [Gold] #543 2016 Topps Baseball$2 ungraded

Alex Wood [Gold] #536 2016 Topps Baseball$1 ungraded

Ivan Nova [Rainbow Foil] #535 2016 Topps Baseball$0 ungraded

Alex Wood [Vintage Stock] #536 2016 Topps Baseball$3 ungraded

Ivan Nova [Vintage Stock] #535 2016 Topps Baseball$9 ungraded

Alex Wood [Black] #536 2016 Topps Baseball$9 ungraded

Alex Wood [Rainbow Foil] #536 2016 Topps Baseball$0 ungraded

Ivan Nova [Black] #535 2016 Topps Baseball$9 ungraded

Ivan Nova [Pink] #535 2016 Topps Baseball$4 ungraded

Alex Wood #536 2016 Topps Baseball$2 ungraded

Eduardo Nunez [Vintage Stock] #534 2016 Topps Baseball$5 ungraded

Ivan Nova #535 2016 Topps Baseball$1 ungraded

Eduardo Nunez [Purple] #534 2016 Topps Baseball$4 ungraded

Eduardo Nunez [Pink] #534 2016 Topps Baseball$7 ungraded

Ivan Nova [Gold] #535 2016 Topps Baseball$0 ungraded

Eduardo Nunez [Clear] #534 2016 Topps Baseball$18 ungraded

Eduardo Nunez [Black] #534 2016 Topps Baseball$6 ungraded

Eduardo Nunez #534 2016 Topps Baseball$1 ungraded

Eduardo Nunez [Rainbow Foil] #534 2016 Topps Baseball$2 ungraded

Zack Wheeler [Black] #529 2016 Topps Baseball$28 ungraded

Caleb Cotham [Gold] #530 2016 Topps Baseball$2 ungraded

Zack Wheeler [Purple] #529 2016 Topps Baseball$4 ungraded

Zack Wheeler [Vintage Stock] #529 2016 Topps Baseball$4 ungraded

Jonathan Villar [Black] #533 2016 Topps Baseball$5 ungraded

Caleb Cotham [Vintage Stock] #530 2016 Topps Baseball$1 ungraded

Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.