The best 1986 Topps Baseball cards under $20 (2026)
The strongest 1986 Topps Baseball cards you can buy for under $20 right now, ranked by real closed-sale prices — not guesses, not asking prices. Updated August 2026; the order shifts as the market does.
Also: under $50 · under $100
- 1
- 2
Ron Mathis #476 1986 Topps Baseball$3.42· $49.99 new/sealed - 3
Gene Nelson #493 1986 Topps Baseball$3.13· $81 new/sealed - 4
- 5
Ozzie Guillen #254 1986 Topps Baseball$2· $77.64 new/sealed - 6
Joe Nolan #781 1986 Topps Baseball$1.99· $4.99 new/sealed - 7
Nolan Ryan #100 1986 Topps Baseball$1.99· $4,049 new/sealed - 8
Dave Winfield #70 1986 Topps Baseball$1.98· $164.5 new/sealed - 9
Don Slaught #761 1986 Topps Baseball$1.96· $50.8 new/sealed - 10
Stu Cliburn #179 1986 Topps Baseball$1.93· $20.5 new/sealed - 11
Roger Clemens #661 1986 Topps Baseball$1.88· $365.58 new/sealed - 12
Bert Roberge #154 1986 Topps Baseball$1.87· $14 new/sealed - 13
Larry Andersen #183 1986 Topps Baseball$1.81· $72.86 new/sealed - 14
Tony Perez #85 1986 Topps Baseball$1.79· $74.99 new/sealed - 15
Cal Ripken Jr. #340 1986 Topps Baseball$1.79· $479.95 new/sealed - 16
Cecil Fielder #386 1986 Topps Baseball$1.78· $719.5 new/sealed - 17
Kirby Puckett #329 1986 Topps Baseball$1.77· $242.17 new/sealed - 18
Harold Reynolds #769 1986 Topps Baseball$1.76· $116.25 new/sealed - 19
Pete O'Brien #328 1986 Topps Baseball$1.76· $15.75 new/sealed - 20
Ernie Camacho #509 1986 Topps Baseball$1.75· $21.42 new/sealed - 21
Phil Niekro #790 1986 Topps Baseball$1.75· $129.5 new/sealed - 22
Steve Henderson #748 1986 Topps Baseball$1.75· $25.77 new/sealed - 23
Dan Petry #540 1986 Topps Baseball$1.75· $38.55 new/sealed - 24
Ken Dixon #198 1986 Topps Baseball$1.75· $77.56 new/sealed - 25
Razor Shines #132 1986 Topps Baseball$1.75· $193.45 new/sealed - 26
Dan Spillner #423 1986 Topps Baseball$1.74· $16.49 new/sealed - 27
Bob James #467 1986 Topps Baseball$1.74· $32.81 new/sealed - 28
Bobby Wine #57 1986 Topps Baseball$1.74· $31 new/sealed - 29
Don Mattingly #712 1986 Topps Baseball$1.73· $97.5 new/sealed - 30
George Foster #680 1986 Topps Baseball$1.73· $201 new/sealed - 31
Darryl Strawberry #80 1986 Topps Baseball$1.73· $124 new/sealed - 32
Rich Bordi #94 1986 Topps Baseball$1.73· $130.93 new/sealed - 33
Dave Van Gorder #143 1986 Topps Baseball$1.72· $8 new/sealed - 34
Steve Buechele #397 1986 Topps Baseball$1.71· $152.39 new/sealed - 35
Dwight Gooden #202 1986 Topps Baseball$1.69· $90 new/sealed - 36
Dwight Gooden #709 1986 Topps Baseball$1.69· $87.06 new/sealed - 37
Ken Landreaux #782 1986 Topps Baseball$1.69· $125 new/sealed - 38
Bob Rodgers #141 1986 Topps Baseball$1.69· $26.67 new/sealed - 39
Kirk Gibson #295 1986 Topps Baseball$1.69· $124.99 new/sealed - 40
Mike Krukow #752 1986 Topps Baseball$1.69· $30 new/sealed - 41
Keith Hernandez #520 1986 Topps Baseball$1.69· $250.26 new/sealed - 42
- 43
- 44
Dick Williams #681 1986 Topps Baseball$1.69· $24.87 new/sealed - 45
Fred Lynn #55 1986 Topps Baseball$1.69· $128.67 new/sealed - 46
Glenn Davis #389 1986 Topps Baseball$1.68· $36 new/sealed - 47
Mike Marshall #728 1986 Topps Baseball$1.67· $55.25 new/sealed - 48
Glenn Wilson #736 1986 Topps Baseball$1.67· $27.55 new/sealed - 49
Don Mattingly #180 1986 Topps Baseball$1.67· $1,010 new/sealed - 50
Keith Hernandez #701 1986 Topps Baseball$1.67· $99.44 new/sealed
Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.