The Most Valuable 1986 Topps Baseball Cards
Ranked by real closed-sale prices across 795 tracked 1986 Topps Baseball items — not guesses, not asking prices. Updated August 2026; the order shifts as the market does. Right now the crown belongs to Don Mattingly [Blank Back] #180 1986 Topps Baseball at $89.5.
On a budget: under $20 · under $50 · under $100
Top 10 by sold value used new / sealed
- 1
![Don Mattingly [Blank Back] #180 1986 Topps Baseball](/api/images/junkpal-products/sports/don-mattingly-blank-back-180-baseball-cards-1986-topps-sport/thumb.webp)
- 2
![Roger Clemens [Blue Streak] #661 1986 Topps Baseball](/api/images/junkpal-products/sports/roger-clemens-blue-streak-661-baseball-cards-1986-topps-sport/thumb.webp)
- 3
- 4
Ron Mathis #476 1986 Topps Baseball$3.42· $49.99 new/sealed - 5
Gene Nelson #493 1986 Topps Baseball$3.13· $81 new/sealed - 6
- 7
Ozzie Guillen #254 1986 Topps Baseball$2· $77.64 new/sealed - 8
Nolan Ryan #100 1986 Topps Baseball$1.99· $4,049 new/sealed - 9
Joe Nolan #781 1986 Topps Baseball$1.99· $4.99 new/sealed - 10
Dave Winfield #70 1986 Topps Baseball$1.98· $164.5 new/sealed - 11
Don Slaught #761 1986 Topps Baseball$1.96· $50.8 new/sealed - 12
Stu Cliburn #179 1986 Topps Baseball$1.93· $20.5 new/sealed - 13
Roger Clemens #661 1986 Topps Baseball$1.88· $365.58 new/sealed - 14
Bert Roberge #154 1986 Topps Baseball$1.87· $14 new/sealed - 15
Larry Andersen #183 1986 Topps Baseball$1.81· $72.86 new/sealed - 16
Cal Ripken Jr. #340 1986 Topps Baseball$1.79· $479.95 new/sealed - 17
Tony Perez #85 1986 Topps Baseball$1.79· $74.99 new/sealed - 18
Cecil Fielder #386 1986 Topps Baseball$1.78· $719.5 new/sealed - 19
Kirby Puckett #329 1986 Topps Baseball$1.77· $242.17 new/sealed - 20
Pete O'Brien #328 1986 Topps Baseball$1.76· $15.75 new/sealed - 21
Harold Reynolds #769 1986 Topps Baseball$1.76· $116.25 new/sealed - 22
Ken Dixon #198 1986 Topps Baseball$1.75· $77.56 new/sealed - 23
Razor Shines #132 1986 Topps Baseball$1.75· $193.45 new/sealed - 24
Ernie Camacho #509 1986 Topps Baseball$1.75· $21.42 new/sealed - 25
Phil Niekro #790 1986 Topps Baseball$1.75· $129.5 new/sealed - 26
Steve Henderson #748 1986 Topps Baseball$1.75· $25.77 new/sealed - 27
Dan Petry #540 1986 Topps Baseball$1.75· $38.55 new/sealed - 28
Bob James #467 1986 Topps Baseball$1.74· $32.81 new/sealed - 29
Dan Spillner #423 1986 Topps Baseball$1.74· $16.49 new/sealed - 30
Bobby Wine #57 1986 Topps Baseball$1.74· $31 new/sealed - 31
Darryl Strawberry #80 1986 Topps Baseball$1.73· $124 new/sealed - 32
Rich Bordi #94 1986 Topps Baseball$1.73· $130.93 new/sealed - 33
Don Mattingly #712 1986 Topps Baseball$1.73· $97.5 new/sealed - 34
George Foster #680 1986 Topps Baseball$1.73· $201 new/sealed - 35
Dave Van Gorder #143 1986 Topps Baseball$1.72· $8 new/sealed - 36
Steve Buechele #397 1986 Topps Baseball$1.71· $152.39 new/sealed - 37
Dwight Gooden #202 1986 Topps Baseball$1.69· $90 new/sealed - 38
Keith Hernandez #520 1986 Topps Baseball$1.69· $250.26 new/sealed - 39
Ken Landreaux #782 1986 Topps Baseball$1.69· $125 new/sealed - 40
Bob Rodgers #141 1986 Topps Baseball$1.69· $26.67 new/sealed - 41
Kirk Gibson #295 1986 Topps Baseball$1.69· $124.99 new/sealed - 42
Mike Krukow #752 1986 Topps Baseball$1.69· $30 new/sealed - 43
Dick Williams #681 1986 Topps Baseball$1.69· $24.87 new/sealed - 44
- 45
Dwight Gooden #709 1986 Topps Baseball$1.69· $87.06 new/sealed - 46
- 47
Fred Lynn #55 1986 Topps Baseball$1.69· $128.67 new/sealed - 48
Glenn Davis #389 1986 Topps Baseball$1.68· $36 new/sealed - 49
Glenn Wilson #736 1986 Topps Baseball$1.67· $27.55 new/sealed - 50
Tom Seaver #390 1986 Topps Baseball$1.67· $79.99 new/sealed
Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.
More rankings
2024 Panini Prizm Football Cards2024 Panini Prizm Basketball Cards2024 Topps Baseball Cards2023 Panini Prizm Football Cards2025 Panini Prizm Football Cards2025 Topps Baseball Cards2021 Panini Prizm Football Cards2023 Panini Prizm Basketball Cards2025 Topps Chrome Football Cards2024 Panini Select Football Cards2021 Panini Prizm Basketball Cards2022 Topps Baseball CardsAll rankings →