Magic Darts — Loose vs Complete (CIB) vs Sealed (new): which is worth more?

Magic Darts value — Loose $12 vs Complete (CIB) $38. Complete (CIB) sells for 3.17× Loose (+217%). Prices updated July 2026.

→ Steady

ConditionSold medianvs Loose

Loose$12—eBay ↗

Complete (CIB)$383.17× · +217%eBay ↗

Sealed (new)$15012.5× · +1150%eBay ↗

Graded (WATA/CGC)$50442× · +4100%eBay ↗

Medians of real sold listings per condition, updated July 2026 — how we compute values.

Loose vs Complete (CIB)

$12→$38

Complete (CIB) sells for 3.17× (+217%) the Loose price — a $26 difference per game.

Complete (CIB) vs Sealed (new)

$38→$150

Sealed (new) sells for 3.95× (+295%) the Complete (CIB) price — a $112 difference per game.

Is complete worth it?

Complete (CIB) $38 vs Loose $12 — a $26 premium (+217%). If you're holding the box and manual, completing a loose copy pays when that premium beats what the missing pieces cost you.

See current eBay listings See sold Magic Darts listings ↗Full Magic Darts price guide →

Values are estimates from real sales data — not appraisals or offers. Some links earn JunkPal a commission at no cost to you (disclosure).