The Most Valuable From Nightmares Cards
Ranked by real closed-sale prices across 170 tracked From Nightmares items — not guesses, not asking prices. Updated August 2026; the order shifts as the market does. Right now the crown belongs to From Nightmares Booster Box (From Nightmares) at $249.24.
On a budget: under $20 · under $50 · under $100
Top 10 by sold value used new / sealed
- 1
From Nightmares Booster Box (From Nightmares)$249.24· $299.97 new/sealed - 2
Custom Starter Set Final Fantasy XIII (From Nightmares)$80.17· $88.9 new/sealed - 3
From Nightmares Prerelease Kit (From Nightmares)$59.82· $59.99 new/sealed - 4
Warrior of Light Full Art (From Nightmares)$55.93· $100 new/sealed - 5
Rydia Full Art (From Nightmares)$38.78· $42.68 new/sealed - 6
Lightning 19 082H Full Art (From Nightmares)$38.44· $119.99 new/sealed - 7
Yshtola (From Nightmares)$20.82· $50 new/sealed - 8
Lenna Full Art Reprint (From Nightmares)$20.58· $49.99 new/sealed - 9
Yuna Full Art Reprint (From Nightmares)$20.17· $69.99 new/sealed - 10
Rufus Road to Worlds 2024 (From Nightmares)$19.62· $49 new/sealed - 11
Sarah MOBIUS 19 024L Full Art (From Nightmares)$18.99· $25 new/sealed - 12
Prishe Full Art (From Nightmares)$18.34· $49.99 new/sealed - 13
Golbez Full Art (From Nightmares)$18.19· $21.99 new/sealed - 14
Unei (From Nightmares)$17.37· $41.5 new/sealed - 15
Bahamut Full Art (From Nightmares)$15.61· $18.72 new/sealed - 16
Lightning 19 138S Full Art (From Nightmares)$13.75· $33 new/sealed - 17
Ricard Full Art (From Nightmares)$13.69· $19 new/sealed - 18
Sabin Full Art (From Nightmares)$9.69· $13.99 new/sealed - 19
Vayne Full Art (From Nightmares)$7.69· $14 new/sealed - 20
From Nightmares Booster Pack (From Nightmares)$6.36· $6.36 new/sealed - 21
Lightning 19 138S (From Nightmares)$6.34· $14.99 new/sealed - 22
Hilda Full Art (From Nightmares)$6.18· $20 new/sealed - 23
Edgar Full Art (From Nightmares)$5.58· $7 new/sealed - 24
Hope (From Nightmares)$5.4· $14.99 new/sealed - 25
Cherukiki Full Art (From Nightmares)$4.99· $10 new/sealed - 26
Prishe (From Nightmares)$4.49· $16.99 new/sealed - 27
Warrior of Light (From Nightmares)$4.35· $35.38 new/sealed - 28
Ace Full Art (From Nightmares)$4· $25 new/sealed - 29
Zidane Full Art (From Nightmares)$3.41· $120 new/sealed - 30
Leon Full Art (From Nightmares)$3.26· $13 new/sealed - 31
Kukki Chebukki Full Art (From Nightmares)$3.26· $12.99 new/sealed - 32
Behemoth 19 066C Full Art (From Nightmares)$3.24· $15 new/sealed - 33
Zidane (From Nightmares)$3.19· $9.99 new/sealed - 34
Larsa Full Art (From Nightmares)$3.1· $11.99 new/sealed - 35
Chimera Full Art (From Nightmares)$2.88· $12.99 new/sealed - 36
Makki Chebukki Full Art (From Nightmares)$2.75· $18.01 new/sealed - 37
Locke Full Art Reprint (From Nightmares)$2.53· $21.94 new/sealed - 38
Bahamut (From Nightmares)$2.26· $4.98 new/sealed - 39
Cloud (From Nightmares)$2.1· $15 new/sealed - 40
Sarah MOBIUS 19 024L (From Nightmares)$1.96· $5.5 new/sealed - 41
Crystal Token Water Full Art Reprint (From Nightmares)$1.83· $10 new/sealed - 42
Yuna 19 118L (From Nightmares)$1.71· $7.99 new/sealed - 43
Noel (From Nightmares)$1.66· $15 new/sealed - 44
Relm (From Nightmares)$1.48· $9.99 new/sealed - 45
Serah EX (From Nightmares)$1.44· $3 new/sealed - 46
Refia (From Nightmares)$0.99· $6.5 new/sealed - 47
Cid Raines (From Nightmares)$0.89· $2.99 new/sealed - 48
Fang (From Nightmares)$0.88· $2.99 new/sealed - 49
Vanille EX (From Nightmares)$0.86· $7 new/sealed - 50
Vayne (From Nightmares)$0.77· $8 new/sealed
Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.