Retro Toys resale values

155 Retro Toys priced on real sold comps, ranging from $1 to $35. See what each is worth — loose or complete — before you buy or sell.

Updated August 2026 · prices refresh as new sales close.

Player Piece #54 (Retro Toys)$5 occasion

King Kandy #58 (Retro Toys)$4 occasion

Queen Frostine #57 (Retro Toys)$5 occasion

Jolly #56 (Retro Toys)$9 occasion

Mr. Mint #55 (Retro Toys)$4 occasion

Colonel Mustard With The Revolver #53 (Retro Toys)$2 occasion

Scarlett #74 (Retro Toys)$2 occasion

Mrs. Peacock With The Knife [Hot Topic] #52 (Retro Toys)$3 occasion

Glo Worm [GITD] #13 (Retro Toys)$9 occasion

Kobra Khan #41 (Retro Toys)$4 occasion

Grizzlor [Flocked] #40 (Retro Toys)$6 occasion

Grizzlor #40 (Retro Toys)$4 occasion

Jetfire #35 (Retro Toys)$22 occasion

Mr. Monopoly in Jail #32 (Retro Toys)$1 occasion

Mr. Monopoly Beauty Contest #31 (Retro Toys)$7 occasion

My Pet Monster #29 (Retro Toys)$15 occasion

Bumblebee #23 (Retro Toys)$4 occasion

Optimus Prime [Amazon] #22 (Retro Toys)$4 occasion

Casey Jones #20 (Retro Toys)$3 occasion

Leonardo #16 (Retro Toys)$4 occasion

Raphael #19 (Retro Toys)$5 occasion

Red Rocker #15 (Retro Toys)$5 occasion

Blue Bomber #14 (Retro Toys)$5 occasion

Donatello #17 (Retro Toys)$6 occasion

Michelangelo #18 (Retro Toys)$5 occasion

Metalhead #21 (Retro Toys)$5 occasion

Starscream #27 (Retro Toys)$9 occasion

Furby Tiger #33 (Retro Toys)$5 occasion

April O'Neil #34 (Retro Toys)$15 occasion

Soundwave #37 (Retro Toys)$8 occasion

Optimus Prime #44 (Retro Toys)$7 occasion

Bumblebee #28 (Retro Toys)$7 occasion

Beach Head #13 (Retro Toys)$5 occasion

Peaches 'N Cream Barbie #6 (Retro Toys)$12 occasion

P.C. Popple #2 (Retro Toys)$6 occasion

Nemesis Prime #36 (Retro Toys)$15 occasion

Mrs. White with the Wrench #51 (Retro Toys)$6 occasion

She-Ra [WonderCon 3000] #38 (Retro Toys)$24 occasion

Plumpy #59 (Retro Toys)$12 occasion

She-Ra [Wondrous 3000] #38 (Retro Toys)$17 occasion

Shipwreck #10 (Retro Toys)$6 occasion

Leatherneck #9 (Retro Toys)$8 occasion

Holiday Barbie 1988 #8 (Retro Toys)$6 occasion

Day-to-Night Barbie #7 (Retro Toys)$7 occasion

Barbie and the Rockers #5 (Retro Toys)$13 occasion

Prize Popple [Chase] #2 (Retro Toys)$12 occasion

Prize Popple #2 (Retro Toys)$3 occasion

Stretch Armstrong [Chase] #1 (Retro Toys)$9 occasion

Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.