Nightfall: First Edition resale values

176 Nightfall: First Edition priced on real sold comps, ranging from $0 to $36. See what each is worth — loose or complete — before you buy or sell.

Updated August 2026 · prices refresh as new sales close.

Dawn (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Possession (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Dark Watchers (Nightfall: First Edition)$1 occasion

Dark Lightning Orb (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Land Tax (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Headless Nun (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Qalupalik (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Crystallized Light (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Lightning Alley (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Bloodlust (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Righteous Reckoning (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Desert (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Unlucky Potion (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Holy Eyes (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

City (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Bell Witch (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Nightmare (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Bubbling Brew (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Pyre (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Destroy Aura (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Napa Rebobs (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Ludwig (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Index (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Raining (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Hells Gate (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Boost Aura (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Cabbagetown Tunnel Monster (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Lightning Storm (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Ocean (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Bursting Spiderlings (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Zombie Apocalypse (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Lufferlang (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Veggieman (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Hope Diamond (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Iceberg (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Nightshade (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Potion Seller (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Oklahoma Octopus (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Witchs Lightning (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Bloody Bones (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Water Baby Of Massacre Rock (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Wunk (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Lightning Aura (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Mountain (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Permafrost (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Obsidian Obelisk (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Winter (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Poltergeist (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 occasion

Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.