Beanie Babies resale values
1,814 Beanie Babies priced on real sold comps. See what each is worth — loose or complete — before you buy or sell.
Updated August 2026 · prices refresh as new sales close.
Issy Puerto Rico Beanie Baby
Patti (magenta) (BBOC Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Louie (Lobster) Beanie Baby
Pi (Canada, Australia, New Zealand & Ty Store Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Iggy (correct fabric) Beanie Baby
Gracie (2014 reissue) (Cub's Ty Tag) (Sports Promos Exclusive) Beanie Baby
New York Rangers Beanie Baby
Garfield (stuck on you) Beanie Baby
Kevin Harvick No. 29 Beanie Baby
Rescue (Ty Store Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Legs (BBOC Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Union Jack Peppa (UK Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Dad (yellow A) Beanie Baby
June (Neck Ruffle) Beanie Baby
Romeo Beanie Baby
Champion Russia Beanie Baby
Hello Kitty (Halloween red devil) Beanie Baby
Amigo (Ty Store Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Gallops (big eyes) Beanie Baby
Gift (Peace) (Hallmark Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Eggs 2008 (2.0) Beanie Baby
Haunting Beanie Baby
Angel (Lilo & Stitch) Beanie Baby
Melton (Walgreens Exclusive) Beanie Baby
M (M Beanie) Beanie Baby
Philadelphia (Trade Show Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Decade (Brown) (Ty Store Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Uncle Sam (tan) Beanie Baby
Ghoul Beanie Baby
Charlie Beanie Baby
Gobbles Beanie Baby
Grandfather (Ty Store Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Hello Kitty (Christmas reindeer antlers) Beanie Baby
Kanata Prince Edward Is (Canada Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Fitz Beanie Baby
Billionaire 13 (Ty Employees Exclusive) Beanie Baby
August (Neck Ruffle) Beanie Baby
Deke Key-Clip (Canada Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Derby 132 (Kentucky Derby Store Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Olaf (sound) (Europe Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Digger (orange body) Beanie Baby
Sam (Blue) Beanie Baby
Emmett Beanie Baby
Jake Beanie Baby
Santa Maria (Ty Store Exclusive) Beanie Baby
V (V Beanie) Beanie Baby
Nala (with sound) Beanie Baby
Happy Hanukkah (menorrah) Beanie Baby
Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.