Mr. Peanutbutter #230 (Animation) — Out of Box vs In Box (damaged) vs New (in box): which is worth more?
Mr. Peanutbutter #230 (Animation) value — Out of Box $28 vs In Box (damaged) $44. In Box (damaged) sells for 1.57× Out of Box (+57%). Prices updated September 2026.
Medians of real sold listings per condition, updated September 2026 — how we compute values.
In Box (damaged) sells for 1.57× (+57%) the Out of Box price — a $16 difference per item.
New (in box) sells for 1.02× (+2%) the In Box (damaged) price — a $1 difference per item.
Is complete worth it?
In Box (damaged) $44 vs Out of Box $28 — a $16 premium (+57%). If you're holding the box and manual, completing a loose copy pays when that premium beats what the missing pieces cost you.
Values are estimates from real sales data — not appraisals or offers. Some links earn JunkPal a commission at no cost to you (disclosure).