Shield Nickel resale values
59 Shield Nickel priced on real sold comps, ranging from $11 to $67,100. See what each is worth — loose or complete — before you buy or sell.
Updated August 2026 · prices refresh as new sales close.
1883/2 Shield Nickel$137 used
1883 Shield Nickel$34 used
1883 [PROOF] Shield Nickel$372 used
1873 [LARGE/SMALL FS-1301] Shield Nickel$3000 used
1874 [PROOF] Shield Nickel$823 used
1875 [PROOF] Shield Nickel$1225 used
1876 [PROOF] Shield Nickel$475 used
1878 [PROOF] Shield Nickel$545 used
1879 Shield Nickel$672 used
1879 [PROOF] Shield Nickel$863 used
1881 [PROOF] Shield Nickel$618 used
1871 [PROOF] Shield Nickel$383 used
1872 Shield Nickel$23 used
1873 Shield Nickel$22 used
1873 [CLOSED 3] Shield Nickel$65 used
1874 Shield Nickel$45 used
1874 [DOUBLE DIE] Shield Nickel$179 used
1875 Shield Nickel$28 used
1876 Shield Nickel$36 used
1877 [PROOF] Shield Nickel$3127 used
1880 Shield Nickel$710 used
1880 [PROOF] Shield Nickel$835 used
1882 [PROOF] Shield Nickel$417 used
1881 Shield Nickel$357 used
1872 [DOUBLE DIE] Shield Nickel$175 used
1872 [PROOF] Shield Nickel$419 used
1873 [CLOSED 3 DOUBLE DIE] Shield Nickel$240 used
1873 [CLOSED 3 PROOF] Shield Nickel$632 used
1873 [DOUBLE DIE CLOSED 3 FS-101] Shield Nickel$195 used
1873 [OPEN 3] Shield Nickel$37 used
1874 [DOUBLE DIE FS-102] Shield Nickel$195 used
1874 [TYPE 2] Shield Nickel$73 used
1875 [DOUBLE DIE FS-101] Shield Nickel$138 used
1875 [DOUBLE DIE] Shield Nickel$33 used
1876 [DOUBLE DIE] Shield Nickel$129 used
1882 Shield Nickel$18 used
1869 [PROOF] Shield Nickel$545 used
1867 [RAYS PROOF] Shield Nickel$67100 used
1870 [PROOF] Shield Nickel$302 used
1868 [PROOF] Shield Nickel$20 used
1866 [RAYS] Shield Nickel$17 used
1867 [DOUBLE DIE] Shield Nickel$52 used
1867 [NO RAYS PROOF] Shield Nickel$80 used
1867 [NO RAYS] Shield Nickel$17 used
1868 Shield Nickel$11 used
1868 [DOUBLE DIE FS-106] Shield Nickel$425 used
1868 [FS-901] Shield Nickel$116 used
1868 [FS-905] Shield Nickel$25 used
Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.
Page 1 of 2