Sesame Street resale values

20 Sesame Street priced on real sold comps, ranging from $8 to $70. See what each is worth — loose or complete — before you buy or sell.

Updated August 2026 · prices refresh as new sales close.

Elmo #8 (Sesame Street)$10 out of box

Bert #4 (Sesame Street)$10 out of box

Super Grover #1 (Sesame Street)$11 out of box

Super Grover [Flocked] #1 (Sesame Street)$30 out of box

Oscar the Grouch [Orange] #3 (Sesame Street)$13 out of box

Ernie #5 (Sesame Street)$17 out of box

The Count #7 (Sesame Street)$22 out of box

Big Bird #10 (Sesame Street)$14 out of box

Herry Monster #11 (Sesame Street)$8 out of box

Mr. Snuffleupagus #6 (Sesame Street)$28 out of box

Cookie Monster #2 (Sesame Street)$17 out of box

Cookie Monster [Flocked] #2 (Sesame Street)$22 out of box

Oscar the Grouch [Green] #3 (Sesame Street)$10 out of box

Bert [Flocked] #4 (Sesame Street)$22 out of box

Ernie [Flocked] #5 (Sesame Street)$15 out of box

Mr. Snuffleupagus [Flocked] #6 (Sesame Street)$25 out of box

Elmo [Flocked] #8 (Sesame Street)$21 out of box

Grover #9 (Sesame Street)$15 out of box

Big Bird [Flocked] #10 (Sesame Street)$13 out of box

Super Grover [Pre-Release] #1 (Sesame Street)$70 out of box

Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.