Nightfall: First Edition resale values

176 Nightfall: First Edition priced on real sold comps, ranging from $0 to $36. See what each is worth — loose or complete — before you buy or sell.

Updated August 2026 · prices refresh as new sales close.

Sinister Shadows (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used

Belled Buzzard (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used

The Red Ghost (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used

Dynamite Token (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used

Full Moon (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used

Abduction (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used

Robert The Doll (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used

Teakettler (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used

Graveyards Mud (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used

Smokescreen (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used

Torrential River (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used

Earth Aura (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used

Axehandle Hound (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used

Earths Binding (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used

Beast of Bladenboro (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used

Smokey Spirits (Nightfall: First Edition)$1 used

River Of Time (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used

Flood The Earth (Nightfall: First Edition)$1 used

Snowing (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used

Spiderling Token (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used

Absorb Aura (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used

Sams Holy Water (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used

Tuttle Bottoms Monster (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used

Shadow Token (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used

Dusk (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used

Island (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used

Jack Frost (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used

Simultaneous Bioluminescence (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used

Excavation (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used

Spirit Aura (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used

Teihiihan (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used

Nightfall First Edition Booster Box (Nightfall: First Edition)$36 used

Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.