Nightfall: First Edition resale values
176 Nightfall: First Edition priced on real sold comps, ranging from $0 to $36. See what each is worth — loose or complete — before you buy or sell.
Updated September 2026 · prices refresh as new sales close.
Shop Nightfall: First Edition on eBay ↗The Most Valuable Nightfall: First Edition Cards →Ask AI about Nightfall: First Edition →
Copy Cup (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used
Borne From The Earth (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used
Meteor Shower (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used
Boil Over (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used
Blessed (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used
Release Event Medal (Nightfall: First Edition)$4 used
Wood Devil of Coos Country (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used
Water To Wine (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used
Nighttime (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used
Cosmic Warp (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used
Mermaids Shimmer (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used
Boogeyman (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used
Wendigo (Nightfall: First Edition)$1 used
Old Books Crying Tree (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used
Light Aura (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used
Imprisonment (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used
Headless Horseman (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used
Dark Aura (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used
Crazy Critter of Bald Mountain (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used
Daytime (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used
Light Elemental (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used
Wallowa Lake Crustacean (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used
Murphysboro Mud Monster (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used
Vampire Mercy Brown (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used
Black Eyed Children (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used
Dampen (Nightfall: First Edition)$1 used
Brain In A Jar (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used
Zombie Token (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used
Iliamna Lake Monster (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used
Water Aura (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used
Momo (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used
Kinderhook Blob (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used
Lake (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used
Nameless Token (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used
Mothman (Nightfall: First Edition)$1 used
Nightfall First Edition Spoiler Pack (Nightfall: First Edition)$20 used
Caster Center MD (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used
Cosmic Aura (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used
Tribal Warcry (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used
Farm (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used
Forest (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used
Stars (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used
Ground (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used
Aura Prowess (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used
Halloween Ghost Sheet (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used
Fog (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used
Air Rods (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used
Exquisite Stew (Nightfall: First Edition)$0 used
Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.