Magic Starter 1999 resale values

175 Magic Starter 1999 priced on real sold comps, ranging from $0 to $3,500. See what each is worth — loose or complete — before you buy or sell.

Updated September 2026 · prices refresh as new sales close.

Charging Paladin$0 ungraded

Starter Game$18 ungraded

Sea Eagle$1 ungraded

Dakmor Sorceress$6 ungraded

Wood Elves$3 ungraded

Goblin General$5 ungraded

Booster Pack$47 ungraded

Time Warp$17 ungraded

Angel of Light$4 ungraded

Plains #157$1 ungraded

Dakmor Scorpion$0 ungraded

Lynx$1 ungraded

Stone Rain$1 ungraded

Grim Tutor$71 ungraded

Dark Offering$0 ungraded

Booster Box$3500 ungraded

Goblin Commando$1 ungraded

Summer Bloom$5 ungraded

Nature's Lore$3 ungraded

Plains #155$2 ungraded

Goblin Lore$4 ungraded

Armageddon$14 ungraded

Piracy$60 ungraded

Eye Spy$1 ungraded

Last Chance$5 ungraded

Thunder Dragon #119$11 ungraded

Forest #173$1 ungraded

Goblin Cavaliers$1 ungraded

Righteous Fury #23$12 ungraded

Goblin Settler$7 ungraded

Hand of Death$0 ungraded

Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.