Magic Starter 1999 resale values
175 Magic Starter 1999 priced on real sold comps, ranging from $0 to $3,500. See what each is worth — loose or complete — before you buy or sell.
Updated September 2026 · prices refresh as new sales close.
Shop Magic Starter 1999 on eBay ↗The Most Valuable Magic Starter Commander Decks Cards →Ask AI about Magic Starter 1999 →
Forest #170$1 ungraded
Squall$0 ungraded
Island #159$1 ungraded
Plains #154$2 ungraded
Island #161$2 ungraded
Whiptail Wurm$0 ungraded
Air Elemental$1 ungraded
Moon Sprite #133$0 ungraded
Mind Rot$0 ungraded
Southern Elephant$0 ungraded
Scorching Spear$0 ungraded
Thorn Elemental #147$1 ungraded
Royal Trooper$0 ungraded
Island #160$2 ungraded
Forest #171$1 ungraded
Island #158$1 ungraded
Forest #172$1 ungraded
Durkwood Boars$0 ungraded
Extinguish$0 ungraded
Tidings$2 ungraded
Untamed Wilds$0 ungraded
Silverback Ape$3 ungraded
Swamp #165$2 ungraded
Water Elemental$1 ungraded
Mountain #166$2 ungraded
Eager Cadet$0 ungraded
Volcanic Hammer$0 ungraded
Sacred Nectar$0 ungraded
Touch of Brilliance$0 ungraded
Veteran Cavalier$1 ungraded
Snapping Drake$0 ungraded
Merfolk of the Pearl Trident$0 ungraded
Sylvan Basilisk$2 ungraded
Sleight of Hand$1 ungraded
Wild Griffin$0 ungraded
Sylvan Yeti$2 ungraded
Tremor$0 ungraded
Wild Ox$0 ungraded
Willow Elf$0 ungraded
Swamp #164$1 ungraded
Wind Drake$1 ungraded
Storm Crow$0 ungraded
Path of Peace$0 ungraded
Trained Orgg$1 ungraded
Gorilla Warrior$0 ungraded
Royal Falcon$0 ungraded
Border Guard$0 ungraded
Ogre Warrior$0 ungraded
Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.
Page 1 of 4