Magic Lord Of The Rings resale values

1,312 Magic Lord Of The Rings priced on real sold comps, ranging from $0 to $2,000,000. See what each is worth — loose or complete — before you buy or sell.

Updated August 2026 · prices refresh as new sales close.

Knights of Dol Amroth #432$0 ungraded

Horn of Gondor [Extended Art Foil] #377$4 ungraded

Nazgul #727$42 ungraded

The Watcher in the Water #75$9 ungraded

Eagles of the North #7$2 ungraded

Nazgul #725$94 ungraded

Mount Doom [Surge Foil] #754$51 ungraded

Set Booster Pack$14 ungraded

Gimli, Counter of Kills [Showcase] #312$0 ungraded

Bill the Pony #3$1 ungraded

Lash of the Balrog #408$0 ungraded

Second Breakfast #29$0 ungraded

Rivendell #259$7 ungraded

Radagast the Brown [Extended Art] #365$2 ungraded

Oliphaunt #426$0 ungraded

Last March of the Ents #623$27 ungraded

Sauron, the Dark Lord [Surge Foil] #821$28 ungraded

Witch-King Of Angmar [Borderless Poster] #736$78 ungraded

Dunland Crebain #411$0 ungraded

The Balrog, Durin's Bane #405$5 ungraded

Gollum, Patient Plotter [Showcase] #309$1 ungraded

Aragorn, the Uniter #192$6 ungraded

Arwen, Mortal Queen [Prerelease] #193$17 ungraded

Tom Bombadil [Borderless Poster] #745$163 ungraded

Radagast the Brown [Extended Art Foil] #365$4 ungraded

Anduril, Flame of the West [Date Stamped] #236$20 ungraded

Call Of The Ring [Prerelease] #79$11 ungraded

Mirkwood Bats #421$5 ungraded

Witch-King Of Angmar [Serialized] #736$50 ungraded

Nazgul #551$68 ungraded

Fall of Gil-galad #165$2 ungraded

The Shire [Borderless] #345$4 ungraded

Mithril Coat [Foil] #245$42 ungraded

Orcish Bowmasters [Foil] #103$46 ungraded

Nazgul #728$55 ungraded

Frodo Baggins #205$1 ungraded

Glamdring [Extended Art] #787$19 ungraded

Anduril, Flame of the West #236$15 ungraded

Mithril Coat #245$26 ungraded

Radagast the Brown [Borderless Poster Foil] #740$79 ungraded

Frodo Baggins [Showcase Foil] #320$1 ungraded

Tom Bombadil [Showcase] #331$21 ungraded

Orcish Bowmasters [Borderless Foil] #433$70 ungraded

Aragorn, the Uniter [Borderless Foil] #434$24 ungraded

Gandalf the Grey #207$1 ungraded

Sauron, the Dark Lord [Showcase Foil] #329$28 ungraded

Prince Imrahil the Fair #431$1 ungraded

Witch-king of Angmar [Borderless Poster Foil] #736$120 ungraded

Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.