Magic Lord Of The Rings resale values

1,312 Magic Lord Of The Rings priced on real sold comps, ranging from $0 to $2,000,000. See what each is worth — loose or complete — before you buy or sell.

Updated August 2026 · prices refresh as new sales close.

Now for Wrath, Now for Ruin! #24$0 used

East-Mark Cavalier #9$0 used

Eowyn, Lady of Rohan #10$0 used

Gandalf, Friend of the Shire #800$3 used

Lotho, Corrupt Shirriff [Surge Foil] #781$20 used

Flowering of the White Tree [Surge Foil] #759$14 used

Mines of Moria [Borderless] #753$2 used

Aragorn, the Uniter #809$6 used

Tom Bombadil [Surge Foil] #823$47 used

Borne Upon a Wind [Surge Foil] #761$9 used

Rivendell [Surge Foil] #755$15 used

Anduril, Flame of the West [Alternate Art Borderless Foil] #746$62 used

Elven Chorus [Surge Foil] #775$6 used

The Shire [Borderless Surge Foil] #756$12 used

Witch-king of Angmar #803$11 used

Call of the Ring [Surge Foil] #766$10 used

Barad-Dur [Surge Foil] #751$14 used

Saruman Of Many Colors [Borderless Poster Foil] #743$126 used

Nazgul [Silver Foil] #724$64 used

Nazgul [Silver Foil] #726$42 used

Spiteful Banditry [Borderless Poster] #738$49 used

Nazgul [Silver Foil] #727$45 used

The Watcher in the Water [Borderless Poster] #734$55 used

Nazgul #729$47 used

The Shire [Silver Foil] #711$10 used

Nazgul #730$12 used

Spiteful Banditry [Borderless Poster Foil] #738$40 used

Dawn of a New Age [Borderless Poster] #731$37 used

Aragorn, The Uniter [Borderless Poster] #741$48 used

Storm of Saruman [Borderless Poster] #733$27 used

Lotho, Corrupt Shirriff [Showcase Foil] #664$30 used

Anduril, Flame of the West #687$8 used

Minas Tirith [Silver Foil] #707$10 used

Horn Of Gondor [Silver Foil] #691$14 used

Shelob, Child Of Ungoliant [Silver Foil] #681$15 used

Palantir of Orthanc [Showcase] #698$49 used

Barad-dur #704$5 used

Merry, Esquire of Rohan #666$2 used

Palantir Of Orthanc [Showcase Foil] #698$88 used

Radagast the Brown #635$4 used

Flame of Anor #654$6 used

Barad-Dur [Silver Foil] #704$10 used

Delighted Halfling [Silver Foil] #609$32 used

Hew the Entwood #587$3 used

Legolas, Master Archer #624$6 used

Call Of The Ring [Showcase Foil] #530$17 used

Elven Chorus [Showcase Foil] #611$12 used

Orcish Bowmasters [Silver Foil] #554$90 used

Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.