Magic Lord Of The Rings Commander resale values

644 Magic Lord Of The Rings Commander priced on real sold comps, ranging from $0 to $6,074. See what each is worth — loose or complete — before you buy or sell.

Updated August 2026 · prices refresh as new sales close.

The Gaffer #414$14 used

Nazgul Battle-Mace [Borderless] #510$18 used

Too Greedily, Too Deep [Foil] #482$2 used

Lossarnach Captain [Foil] #418$3 used

Osgiliath, Fallen Capital [Foil] #398$20 used

Merry, Warden of Isengard [Foil] #468$5 used

Green Dragon Inn #365$14 used

Elessar, the Elfstone [Foil] #379$22 used

The Gaffer [Foil] #414$19 used

Balin's Tomb [Foil] #387$164 used

Saruman, the White Hand [Extended Art] #91$4 used

The Black Gate #80$9 used

Galadhrim Ambush #38$5 used

Call Forth The Tempest [Borderless Foil] #509$20 used

Treebeard, Gracious Host [Foil] #483$13 used

The Black Gate [Foil] #490$29 used

Forth Eorlingas! [Foil] #460$4 used

Minas Morgul, Dark Fortress [Borderless Foil] #514$15 used

Riders of Rohan #474$1 used

Rammas Echor, Ancient Shield [Surge Foil] #549$16 used

Sunpetal Grove #336$1 used

Hithlain Rope [Extended Art] #156$1 used

The Black Gate #490$29 used

Relic of Sauron [Extended Art] #159$9 used

Eowyn, Shieldmaiden [Showcase] #456$17 used

Isengard, Saruman's Fortress #359$16 used

Sauron, Lord of the Rings #4$1 used

Three Rings for the Elven-Kings #352$14 used

Galadriel's Dismissal [Borderless Foil] #500$25 used

Relic of Sauron [Foil] #489$20 used

Forth Eorlingas! [Showcase Foil] #460$22 used

Galadriel, Light Of Valinor [Surge Foil] #542$76 used

Gimli's Reckless Might [Foil] #494$4 used

Cavern-Hoard Dragon [Extended Art] #114$25 used

Nazgul Battle-Mace [Surge Foil] #554$24 used

Relic of Sauron #489$13 used

Scourge of the Throne #225$0 used

Barrow-Downs [Borderless Foil] #358$31 used

Shards of Narsil #356$2 used

Andúril, Narsil Reforged [Foil] #491$32 used

The Balrog of Moria #449$8 used

Herugrim, Sword of Rohan #354$25 used

Galadriel, Light Of Valinor [Borderless Foil] #498$23 used

Forth Eorlingas! [Extended Art] #139$7 used

Lord of the Nazgul [Showcase] #467$24 used

Raise the Palisade #425$25 used

Arwen, Weaver of Hope #437$21 used

Meduseld, Golden Hall of Edoras [Serialized] #391$1400 used

Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.