Magic Innistrad resale values

548 Magic Innistrad priced on real sold comps, ranging from $0 to $350. See what each is worth — loose or complete — before you buy or sell.

Updated September 2026 · prices refresh as new sales close.

Angel [Token] #1$1 ungraded

Clifftop Retreat$1 ungraded

Mindshrieker [Foil]$2 ungraded

Ambush Viper [Foil]$1 ungraded

Island$0 ungraded

Voiceless Spirit [Foil]$0 ungraded

Brimstone Volley$0 ungraded

Bonds of Faith [Foil]$1 ungraded

Battleground Geist [Foil]$0 ungraded

Dream Twist$0 ungraded

Ghoulcaller's Chant [Foil]$2 ungraded

Avacyn's Pilgrim [Foil]$6 ungraded

Heartless Summoning$2 ungraded

Reaper from the Abyss$1 ungraded

Skaab Ruinator [Foil]$3 ungraded

Cackling Counterpart [Foil]$1 ungraded

Prey Upon$0 ungraded

Undead Alchemist [Foil]$5 ungraded

Angelic Overseer$1 ungraded

Shimmering Grotto$0 ungraded

Runechanter's Pike [Foil]$2 ungraded

Blasphemous Act$2 ungraded

Past in Flames$2 ungraded

Rebuke$0 ungraded

Bump in the Night$0 ungraded

Geistflame #144/264$0 ungraded

Army of the Damned$1 ungraded

Urgent Exorcism$0 ungraded

Traitorous Blood [Foil]$2 ungraded

Grimgrin, Corpse-Born #214$2 ungraded

Thraben Sentry$0 ungraded

Angelic Overseer [Foil]$6 ungraded

Silent Departure$0 ungraded

Bloodgift Demon$1 ungraded

Fiend Hunter$0 ungraded

Mikaeus, the Lunarch$1 ungraded

Village Bell-Ringer [Foil]$11 ungraded

Abbey Griffin$0 ungraded

Geist-Honored Monk [Foil]$2 ungraded

Garruk Relentless$2 ungraded

Booster Pack$18 ungraded

Tree of Redemption #207$3 ungraded

Olivia Voldaren [Foil]$16 ungraded

Stitched Drake$0 ungraded

Isolated Chapel$1 ungraded

Avacynian Priest$0 ungraded

Mulch$0 ungraded

Laboratory Maniac$3 ungraded

Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.