Magic Innistrad Midnight Hunt resale values

694 Magic Innistrad Midnight Hunt priced on real sold comps, ranging from $0 to $204. See what each is worth — loose or complete — before you buy or sell.

Updated August 2026 · prices refresh as new sales close.

Sunstreak Phoenix [Foil] #162$0 used

Rotten Reunion #119$0 used

Saryth, the Viper's Fang [Foil] #197$2 used

Malevolent Hermit & Benevolent Geist [Foil] #61$3 used

Blessed Defiance [Foil] #5$0 used

Crawl from the Cellar #93$0 used

Ritual Guardian [Foil] #30$0 used

Shipwreck Sifters [Foil] #74$0 used

Otherworldly Gaze [Foil] #67$1 used

Siphon Insight [Extended Art] #375$1 used

Hobbling Zombie #106$0 used

Duress [Foil] #98$0 used

Startle #78$0 used

The Celestus [Extended Art] #377$1 used

Gisa, Glorious Resurrector [Foil] #103$4 used

Curse of Leeches & Leeching Lurker [Foil] #94$0 used

Gisa, Glorious Resurrector #103$3 used

Dreadhound [Foil] #97$0 used

Consider [Foil] #44$1 used

Arrogant Outlaw [Foil] #84$0 used

Olivia's Midnight Ambush [Foil] #118$0 used

Skaab Wrangler [Foil] #75$0 used

Hostile Hostel & Creeping Inn [Extended Art] #379$1 used

Foul Play [Foil] #101$0 used

Malevolent Hermit & Benevolent Geist #61$1 used

Ominous Roost [Foil] #65$1 used

Novice Occultist #117$0 used

Diregraf Horde [Foil] #96$0 used

Search Party Captain [Foil] #32$0 used

Wake to Slaughter [Extended Art] #376$0 used

Grafted Identity [Foil] #57$0 used

Secrets of the Key [Foil] #73$0 used

Sludge Monster [Foil] #76$1 used

Larder Zombie [Foil] #58$0 used

Plains #380$0 used

Homestead Courage #24$0 used

Consider #44$0 used

Bloodtithe Collector [Foil] #90$0 used

Stormrider Spirit [Foil] #79$0 used

Firmament Sage [Foil] #53$0 used

Curse of Silence [Foil] #15$1 used

Moonsilver Key [Foil] #255$5 used

Burly Breaker & Dire-Strain Demolisher [Showcase Foil] #299$3 used

Wrenn and Seven [Foil] #278$6 used

Teferi, Who Slows the Sunset [Borderless] #280$5 used

Willow Geist [Foil] #207$0 used

Florian, Voldaren Scion [Showcase] #318$1 used

Sungold Sentinel [Extended Art] #332$0 used

Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.