Magic 5th Edition resale values
453 Magic 5th Edition priced on real sold comps, ranging from $0 to $1,043. See what each is worth — loose or complete — before you buy or sell.
Updated September 2026 · prices refresh as new sales close.
Shop Magic 5th Edition on eBay ↗The Most Valuable Magic 5th Edition Cards →Ask AI about Magic 5th Edition →
Seasinger$1 ungraded
Primal Clay$0 ungraded
Goblin Warrens$1 ungraded
Jandor's Saddlebags$1 ungraded
Greater Werewolf$0 ungraded
Icatian Store$1 ungraded
Giant Growth$0 ungraded
Glacial Wall$0 ungraded
Kjeldoran Skycaptain$0 ungraded
Mindstab Thrull$0 ungraded
Magus of the Unseen$1 ungraded
Karma$1 ungraded
Johtull Wurm$0 ungraded
Lifetap$0 ungraded
Lhurgoyf$1 ungraded
Millstone$1 ungraded
Howl from Beyond$0 ungraded
Knight of Stromgald$1 ungraded
Mons's Goblin Raiders$1 ungraded
Ice Floe$0 ungraded
Living Artifact$1 ungraded
Manabarbs$4 ungraded
Icatian Town$0 ungraded
Fungusaur$0 ungraded
Jayemdae Tome$1 ungraded
Homarid Warrior$0 ungraded
Gloom$0 ungraded
Ironclaw Curse$0 ungraded
Goblin Hero$0 ungraded
Hollow Trees$1 ungraded
Infinite Hourglass$0 ungraded
Heal$0 ungraded
Kjeldoran Royal Guard$0 ungraded
Jalum Tome$1 ungraded
Kismet$1 ungraded
Killer Bees$1 ungraded
Labyrinth Minotaur$0 ungraded
Joven's Tools$0 ungraded
Mind Bomb$0 ungraded
Hecatomb$1 ungraded
Mountain [B]$2 ungraded
Gauntlets of Chaos$0 ungraded
D'Avenant Archer$0 ungraded
Frozen Shade$0 ungraded
Chub Toad$0 ungraded
Circle of Protection: Red$0 ungraded
Evil Presence$0 ungraded
Carapace$0 ungraded
Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.