Icons resale values

187 Icons priced on real sold comps, ranging from $1 to $216. See what each is worth — loose or complete — before you buy or sell.

Updated September 2026 · prices refresh as new sales close.

El Catrin #84 (Icons)$11 out of box

Jimmy Carter #48 (Icons)$8 out of box

Bill Nye #51 (Icons)$7 out of box

Ninja #52 (Icons)$6 out of box

Pizza Rat #54 (Icons)$8 out of box

Pizza Rat [Fall Convention Purple Hat Black Fur] #54 (Icons)$20 out of box

Ronald Reagan #49 (Icons)$8 out of box

Stephen King #53 (Icons)$20 out of box

Farrah Fawcett #50 (Icons)$8 out of box

Jackie Kennedy #47 (Icons)$5 out of box

Mark Hamill [Black] #27 (Icons)$9 out of box

Colonel Sanders [Gold] #5 (Icons)$13 out of box

Rosie the Riveter #8 (Icons)$20 out of box

Abraham Lincoln #10 (Icons)$18 out of box

Washington Crossing the Delaware #11 (Icons)$35 out of box

Uncle Sam #12 (Icons)$10 out of box

Merlion #14 (Icons)$20 out of box

Rat Fink [Gray] #15 (Icons)$16 out of box

MTV Moon Person #18 (Icons)$6 out of box

MTV Moon Person [Gold] #18 (Icons)$17 out of box

Edgar Allan Poe [GITD] #21 (Icons)$18 out of box

Paulie Pigeon #23 (Icons)$4 out of box

Marilyn Monroe #24 (Icons)$16 out of box

Marilyn Monroe [Black & White] #24 (Icons)$10 out of box

Whitney Houston #25 (Icons)$3 out of box

Albert Einstein #26 (Icons)$10 out of box

Mark Hamill #27 (Icons)$15 out of box

Stephen King #44 (Icons)$20 out of box

Ruth Bader Ginsburg #45 (Icons)$7 out of box

Colonel Sanders #5 (Icons)$9 out of box

Rat Fink [Green] #15 (Icons)$17 out of box

Paulie Pigeon [Pinstripe Jersey] #23 (Icons)$26 out of box

Dr. Seuss #3 (Icons)$6 out of box

George Washington #9 (Icons)$13 out of box

Rat Fink [Gray Chrome] #15 (Icons)$11 out of box

Rat Fink [Green Chrome] #15 (Icons)$12 out of box

Kirk Hammett #17 (Icons)$204 out of box

Jim Henson with Ernie #19 (Icons)$9 out of box

Edgar Allan Poe #21 (Icons)$14 out of box

Edgar Allan Poe #22 (Icons)$7 out of box

Paulie Pigeon [Orange Blue] #23 (Icons)$5 out of box

Mark Hamill #28 (Icons)$11 out of box

Bill Nye #29 (Icons)$7 out of box

John F. Kennedy #46 (Icons)$10 out of box

Stephen King #43 (Icons)$14 out of box

Whitney Houston #70 (Icons)$3 out of box

Jim Henson with Kermit #20 (Icons)$12 out of box

Guy Fieri #49 (Icons)$13 out of box

Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.