Horror resale values

30 Horror priced on real sold comps. See what each is worth — loose or complete — before you buy or sell.

Updated August 2026 · prices refresh as new sales close.

Filtered: Capstone · 30 items · clear ×

Maze Monster by Andy Catling

Fall of the House of Usher by Matthew K. Manning

Secrets of the Library of Doom by Michael Dahl

Jeff Allen vs the Time Suck Vampire (Devils' Pass by Justina Ireland

Tiffany Donovan vs. the Cookie Elves of Destruction (Devils' Pass) by Justina Ireland

Evie Allen vs the Quiz Tournament Zombies (Devils' Pass by Justina Ireland

Ooze Is It? by Michael Dahl

Stitch Head by Guy Bass

Zombie winter by Jason Strange

To wake the dead by Jason Strange

Campfire Vampire by John Sazaklis

The mothman's shadow by Jason Strange

Jar of Eyeballs by Michael Dahl

Blood Shark! by Michael Dahl

Werewolf Skin by Michael Dahl

Attack of the Cute by Jaclyn Jaycox

Crows' Warning by Amerigo Pinelli

Library of Doom by Michael Dahl

Portal by Amerigo Pinelli

Witch's Stew by Jaclyn Jaycox

Creature in the Crystal by Neil Evans

Attack of the Mud Creatures by J. A. Darke

Scare Ball by Benjamin Bird

Sorcery Stories to Scare Your Socks Off! by Michael Dahl

Monster Stories to Scare Your Socks Off! by Michael Dahl

Cemetery by Amerigo Pinelli

Tech Fury by J. A. Darke

Grin in the Dark by J. A. Darke

The Screaming Bridge by J. A. Darke

Legend of Sleepy Hollow by Washington Irving

Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.