Caster'S Cup Promo Cards resale values

22 Caster's Cup Promo Cards priced on real sold comps, ranging from $4 to $9,999. See what each is worth — loose or complete — before you buy or sell.

Updated August 2026 · prices refresh as new sales close.

Medford Shmoos (Caster's Cup Promo Cards)$10 used

Anti Potion Potion Player Stamped (Caster's Cup Promo Cards)$9999 used

Icy Path Player Stamped (Caster's Cup Promo Cards)$16 used

Kinderhook Blob Player Stamped (Caster's Cup Promo Cards)$100 used

Paralyze (Caster's Cup Promo Cards)$9 used

Familiar (Caster's Cup Promo Cards)$4 used

Index Staff Stamped (Caster's Cup Promo Cards)$378 used

Hugag (Caster's Cup Promo Cards)$10 used

Water Baby Of Massacre Rock Player Stamped (Caster's Cup Promo Cards)$9999 used

Water Baby Of Massacre Rock (Caster's Cup Promo Cards)$16 used

Boogeyman Player Stamped (Caster's Cup Promo Cards)$9 used

Lava Bear (Caster's Cup Promo Cards)$40 used

Cumberland Spaceman Player Stamped (Caster's Cup Promo Cards)$30 used

Health Potion (Caster's Cup Promo Cards)$20 used

Void Spell (Caster's Cup Promo Cards)$8 used

Wallowa Lake Crustacean Player Stamped (Caster's Cup Promo Cards)$9999 used

Feign Death (Caster's Cup Promo Cards)$9 used

Roperite Player Stamped (Caster's Cup Promo Cards)$9999 used

Chibi Quetza Player Stamped (Caster's Cup Promo Cards)$10 used

Chibi Quetza (Caster's Cup Promo Cards)$15 used

Dingbelle (Caster's Cup Promo Cards)$20 used

A Mi Kuk (Caster's Cup Promo Cards)$39 used

Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.