Beanie Babies resale values
1,814 Beanie Babies priced on real sold comps. See what each is worth — loose or complete — before you buy or sell.
Updated August 2026 · prices refresh as new sales close.
Peace | 05/01/99 SGA | Oakland A's vs Boston Red Sox | MLB Baseball Beanie Baby
Loveypup Beanie Baby
Frank (Redesign) Beanie Baby
Loxie Beanie Baby
Issy Mexico City Beanie Baby
Davey (Davey Voice Org Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Hawaii (Hawaii Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Your Teddy Bear (blue) musical (Walgreens Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Charlie Brown (musical) Beanie Baby
Valentina | 05/30/99 SGA | New York Mets vs Arizona Diamondbacks | MLB Base Beanie Baby
Roxie (Red nose) Beanie Baby
Winnie the Pooh (Classic) Beanie Baby
Wilfred Beanie Baby
Lefty Beanie Baby
Melman Beanie Baby
Haunted (Borders Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Seattle (Trade Show Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Issy Budapest Beanie Baby
Khufu (BBOM Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Pecan (2009) Beanie Baby
Mascotte (Europe Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Glacier Beanie Baby
Issy Cairo Beanie Baby
Rex Beanie Baby
Las Vegas Golden Knights Beanie Baby
Oasis (2.0) Beanie Baby
Hello Kitty (Easter, Spring floral dress, bunny) Beanie Baby
N (N Beanie) Beanie Baby
Outlaw Beanie Baby
Goldie Beanie Baby
Flitter Beanie Baby
Grandpa Pig (UK Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Detroit Tigers Beanie Baby
Patrick Star He Shoots He Scores (UK Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Rintoo Beanie Baby
Alacazam Beanie Baby
Peeps Beanie Baby
Villager (Canada Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Beary Much (Ty Store Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Goodheart Beanie Baby
Joy Beanie Baby
American Blessing (Knott’s Berry Farm Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Feder-bear Beanie Baby
Baltimore Ravens Beanie Baby
Lewis (Santa Barbara Zoo Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Flower (UK Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Hello Kitty (Blue Angel Hello Kitty) (UK Exclusive) Beanie Baby
L (L Beanie) Beanie Baby
Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.