Beanie Babies resale values
1,814 Beanie Babies priced on real sold comps. See what each is worth — loose or complete — before you buy or sell.
Updated August 2026 · prices refresh as new sales close.
Fluttershy Key-Clip (Sparkle) Beanie Baby
Mystic The Unicorn Versions Ty Beanie Babies Beanie Baby
Mango Beanie Baby
Lollipup Beanie Baby
Gary the snail Beanie Baby
Ebony (Hamleys Exclusive) w/cert in a case Beanie Baby
Kiss Hello Kitty (Demon) Beanie Baby
Zip (White Paws) Beanie Baby
Secretariat (US Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Billionaire 18 (Flippables) (Ty Employees Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Billionaire 2 (Ty Employees Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Lani Beanie Baby
Scoop Beanie Baby
JET RAY (UK Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Marty Beanie Baby
Kiss Hello Kitty (Catman) Beanie Baby
Hearts-A-Flutter (Hallmark Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Teddy (teal, NF New Face) Beanie Baby
Majestic (Seahorse sparkly) Beanie Baby
Free (blue chest) (Ty Store Exclusive) Beanie Baby
I (heart) U Beanie Baby
Santa Beanie Baby
McLucky (2.0) (Ty Store Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Kisses (Walgreen’s Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Bidder (MBNA Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Scorch Beanie Baby
Frank (2.0) Beanie Baby
American Beanie Baby
Valor (Ty Store Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Issy Sharm El Sheikh Beanie Baby
Hippity, Hoppity, Floppity Ty Beanie Babies in the Spotlight Beanie Baby
Marshall (Arlington Park Exclusive) Junior Hockey Club (extra tag red text) Beanie Baby
Raicho (chick) (brown top of head) (medium) 96236 (Japan Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Sequoia (2010) Beanie Baby
Kookie Beanie Baby
John Beanie Baby
First Mate Patrick Beanie Baby
T (T Beanie) Beanie Baby
Heather Beanie Baby
Peepers (2009) Beanie Baby
Manny Beanie Baby
Valentino | 06/26/98 SGA | Bolton Bombers vs Morain Valley Com College | NH Beanie Baby
USA (USA Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Catsby Beanie Baby
American Blessing Beanie Baby
Nala Beanie Baby
LEO Football (Leo High School Exclusive) Beanie Baby
L (L Beanie) Beanie Baby
Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.