Beanie Babies resale values
1,814 Beanie Babies priced on real sold comps. See what each is worth — loose or complete — before you buy or sell.
Updated August 2026 · prices refresh as new sales close.
Arctic Beanie Baby
Champion USA Beanie Baby
Patti (deep fuchsia) Beanie Baby
Millenium vs Millennium Ty Beanie Baby Variations and Values Beanie Baby
McDonald's Ty Teenie Beanie Babies what are they worth? Beanie Baby
Schnitzel Beanie Baby
May Beanie Baby
Union (flag nose) (USA Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Rainbow Dash Beanie Baby
Peanut (light blue) Beanie Baby
Daisy (Harry Caray) | 05/03/98 SGA | Chicago Cubs vs St. Louis Cardinals | Beanie Baby
Sherbet (light pink) Beanie Baby
Lot's O'Luck (BBOM Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Petal Beanie Baby
Happy (lavender body) Beanie Baby
Hello Kitty (Easter, pink Bunny ears) Beanie Baby
Eleanor Beanie Baby
Barbaro (Kentucky Derby Store Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Derby 134 (pink) (Kentucky Derby Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Uncle Sam (white) Beanie Baby
Mac Beanie Baby
Florida (Florida Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Alani (BBOM Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Derby 134 (blue) (Churchill Down Store Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Decade (Hot pink) (BBOM Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Dear (Hallmark Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Love Birds (Hallmark Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Filly Beanie Baby
Gracie (2019) (big eyes) Beanie Baby
Issy Boston Beanie Baby
Fraidy Beanie Baby
Lily (big eyes) Beanie Baby
Q (Q Beanie) Beanie Baby
Hairy Beanie Baby
It's a Boy Beanie Baby
Oakdale (Ty Store Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Candy Canes (white) Beanie Baby
J (J Beanie) Beanie Baby
Issy Beirut Beanie Baby
Yang (big eyes) Beanie Baby
Bessie Beanie Baby
Shake, Rattle & Beanie (Walgreens Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Neon Beanie Baby
Philadelphia Phillies Beanie Baby
Hello Kitty (Easter bunny) (Pink Costume) Beanie Baby
Goody (forward) Beanie Baby
Hello Kitty (apple, green) Beanie Baby
L (L Beanie) Beanie Baby
Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.