Beanie Babies resale values
1,814 Beanie Babies priced on real sold comps. See what each is worth — loose or complete — before you buy or sell.
Updated August 2026 · prices refresh as new sales close.
Hello Kitty (Halloween black cat, candy) Beanie Baby
Bali Key-Clip (Pizza Hut Exclusive) Beanie Baby
George Muddy Puddles (UK Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Larry (big eyes) Beanie Baby
Rosita Beanie Baby
Papa (Ty Store Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Gene (Emoji) Beanie Baby
Nana (later as "Bongo") Beanie Baby
Sheets Beanie Baby
Massachusetts (Massachusetts Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Pierre (Canada Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Charles (Harrods Exclusive) w/cert in case Beanie Baby
October Beanie Baby
Marshall (Paw Patrol) Beanie Baby
H (H Beanie) Beanie Baby
New York State (New York Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Rescue Beanie Baby
Kansas (Kansas Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Peekaboo Beanie Baby
Decade (Purple) Beanie Baby
Giving Beanie Baby
Lambie Beanie Baby
George (hat & scarf) (UK Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Hannah Motomachi (Ty Store Japan Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Jailbreak (Emoji) Beanie Baby
Winnie the Pooh (Christmas) (Walgreens Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Peking Beanie Baby
Packer (UK & Harrods Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Meena Beanie Baby
M.C. Anniversary 4th Edition (Ty MBNA Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Scurry Beanie Baby
Roary | 05/31/98 SGA | Kansas City Royals vs Oakland A's | MLB Baseba Beanie Baby
Nibbler Beanie Baby
Jinglepup (white hat, white tail) (Canada Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Billionaire 11 (Ty Employees Exclusive) Beanie Baby
October (Neck Ruffle) Beanie Baby
Banjo Beanie Baby
Amora (CVS Exclusive) Beanie Baby
San Francisco 49ers Beanie Baby
Hello Kitty (fashionista) (pink/red Glasses) Beanie Baby
Teddy (brown, NF New Face) Beanie Baby
Feastings (BBOM Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Tasty Beanie Baby
Heiress Beanie Baby
White Fang Key-Clip (UK Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Wiggy Beanie Baby
Rocket Beanie Baby
L (L Beanie) Beanie Baby
Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.