American Silver Eagle resale values
141 American Silver Eagle priced on real sold comps, ranging from $42 to $750. See what each is worth — loose or complete — before you buy or sell.
Updated August 2026 · prices refresh as new sales close.
1997 American Silver Eagle$80 used
1999 American Silver Eagle$96 used
2001 American Silver Eagle$70 used
2003 American Silver Eagle$83 used
2005 W [PROOF] American Silver Eagle$77 used
1989 S [PROOF] American Silver Eagle$79 used
1990 S [PROOF] American Silver Eagle$86 used
1992 S [PROOF] American Silver Eagle$86 used
2005 American Silver Eagle$75 used
2004 W [PROOF] American Silver Eagle$80 used
2004 American Silver Eagle$69 used
2003 W [PROOF] American Silver Eagle$78 used
2002 W [PROOF] American Silver Eagle$81 used
2002 American Silver Eagle$80 used
2001 W [PROOF] American Silver Eagle$91 used
2000 P [PROOF] American Silver Eagle$90 used
2000 American Silver Eagle$90 used
1999 P [PROOF] American Silver Eagle$77 used
1998 P [PROOF] American Silver Eagle$74 used
1998 American Silver Eagle$81 used
1997 P [PROOF] American Silver Eagle$90 used
1996 P [PROOF] American Silver Eagle$68 used
1996 American Silver Eagle$79 used
1995 American Silver Eagle$106 used
1994 P [PROOF] American Silver Eagle$107 used
1993 P [PROOF] American Silver Eagle$80 used
1993 American Silver Eagle$77 used
1992 American Silver Eagle$80 used
1991 American Silver Eagle$83 used
1995 W American Silver Eagle
1990 American Silver Eagle$89 used
1988 S [PROOF] American Silver Eagle$86 used
1989 American Silver Eagle$97 used
1991 S [PROOF] American Silver Eagle$82 used
1994 American Silver Eagle$140 used
1995 P [PROOF] American Silver Eagle$92 used
2025 W American Silver Eagle$74 used
1986 American Silver Eagle$93 used
1986 S [PROOF] American Silver Eagle$106 used
1987 American Silver Eagle$89 used
1987 S [PROOF] American Silver Eagle$92 used
1988 American Silver Eagle$79 used
1986 S [PROOF MERCANTI SIGNED] American Silver Eagle$235 used
2016 W [PROOF MERCANTI SIGNED] American Silver Eagle
2024 S [PROOF] American Silver Eagle$93 used
Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.
Page 3 of 3