2023 Topps Heritage Baseball resale values

4,340 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball priced on real sold comps, ranging from $0 to $6,999. See what each is worth — loose or complete — before you buy or sell.

Updated August 2026 · prices refresh as new sales close.

Oscar Gonzalez #439 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$2 used

Juan Soto [Red Border] #440 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$8 used

Juan Soto [Black Border] #440 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$8 used

Game 5 HR #437 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$3 used

Hits Home Run in ALDS [Black Border] #441 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$13 used

Single Completes Mariners Comeback #438 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$1 used

Hits Home Run in ALDS #441 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$3 used

Bryce Harper [Black Border] #435 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$47 used

2 HRs in Game 4 #436 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$2 used

Oscar Gonzalez [Red Border] #439 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$4 used

Single Completes Mariners Comeback [Black Border] #438 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$5 used

Astros 3 Games Mariners 0 Games [Black Border] #434 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$14 used

Astros 3 Games Mariners 0 Games [Red Border] #434 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$2 used

Bryce Harper [Flip Stock] #435 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$30 used

Matt Thaiss [Red Border] #431 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$2 used

Bryan Shaw [Black Border] #433 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$8 used

Paul Sewald [Flip Stock] #430 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$6 used

Walker Buehler [Red Border] #432 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$6 used

Cal Quantrill [Black Border] #429 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$5 used

Cal Quantrill [Red Border] #429 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$2 used

Matt Thaiss [Flip Stock] #431 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$4 used

Walker Buehler [Black Border] #432 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$8 used

Paul Sewald [Red Border] #430 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$3 used

Bryan Shaw #433 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$2 used

Paul Sewald [Black Border] #430 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$2 used

Walker Buehler #432 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$2 used

Matt Thaiss [Black Border] #431 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$4 used

Matt Thaiss #431 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$2 used

Bryan Shaw [Red Border] #433 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$4 used

Cal Quantrill #429 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$2 used

Cal Quantrill [Flip Stock] #429 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$13 used

Walker Buehler [Mini] #432 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$14 used

Justin Dunn [Red Border] #428 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$1 used

Astros 3 Games Mariners 0 Games #434 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$2 used

Paul Sewald #430 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$2 used

Eric Haase [Flip Stock] #422 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$19 used

Alex Verdugo #426 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$2 used

Matt Duffy [Red Border] #424 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$6 used

Justin Dunn [Black Border] #428 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$5 used

Joe Kelly [Flip Stock] #423 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$10 used

Eric Haase [Black Border] #422 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$5 used

Kyle Wright [Red Border] #425 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$4 used

Nick Madrigal #427 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$2 used

Matt Duffy #424 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$2 used

Kyle Wright [Black Border] #425 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$6 used

Joe Kelly [Black Border] #423 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$3 used

Nick Madrigal [Flip Stock] #427 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$5 used

Justin Dunn #428 2023 Topps Heritage Baseball$2 used

Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.