1958 Topps Baseball resale values

540 1958 Topps Baseball priced on real sold comps, ranging from $1 to $4,440. See what each is worth — loose or complete — before you buy or sell.

Updated August 2026 · prices refresh as new sales close.

Filtered: 1958 · 540 items · clear ×

Gary Geiger #462 1958 Topps Baseball$4 ungraded

Jackie Jensen [All Star] #489 1958 Topps Baseball$4 ungraded

Don Ferrarese #469 1958 Topps Baseball$3 ungraded

Ed Bailey [All Star] #490 1958 Topps Baseball$2 ungraded

Joe Jay #472 1958 Topps Baseball$2 ungraded

R. C. Stevens #470 1958 Topps Baseball$2 ungraded

Arnie Portocarrero #465 1958 Topps Baseball$2 ungraded

Lenny Green #471 1958 Topps Baseball$3 ungraded

Glen Hobbie #467 1958 Topps Baseball$3 ungraded

Frank Malzone [All Star] #481 1958 Topps Baseball$5 ungraded

Pete Whisenant #466 1958 Topps Baseball$2 ungraded

Ed Mayer #461 1958 Topps Baseball$3 ungraded

Bill Renna #473 1958 Topps Baseball$2 ungraded

Roman Semproch #474 1958 Topps Baseball$2 ungraded

Bob Schmidt #468 1958 Topps Baseball$2 ungraded

Vito Valentinetti #463 1958 Topps Baseball$3 ungraded

Bob Turley [All Star] #493 1958 Topps Baseball$5 ungraded

Ray Monzant #447 1958 Topps Baseball$2 ungraded

Hal Griggs #455 1958 Topps Baseball$2 ungraded

Roman Mejias #452 1958 Topps Baseball$3 ungraded

Billy Harrell #443 1958 Topps Baseball$5 ungraded

Gus Triandos #429 1958 Topps Baseball$3 ungraded

Phil Clark #423 1958 Topps Baseball$2 ungraded

Bob Smith #445 1958 Topps Baseball$4 ungraded

Al Worthington #427 1958 Topps Baseball$4 ungraded

Harry Hanebrink #454 1958 Topps Baseball$3 ungraded

Phil Paine #442 1958 Topps Baseball$3 ungraded

Carroll Hardy #446 1958 Topps Baseball$4 ungraded

Julio Becquer #458 1958 Topps Baseball$2 ungraded

Cincinnati Redlegs [Numerical] #428 1958 Topps Baseball$5 ungraded

John Powers #432 1958 Topps Baseball$3 ungraded

Bob Speake #437 1958 Topps Baseball$4 ungraded

Preston Ward #450 1958 Topps Baseball$4 ungraded

Charlie Lau #448 1958 Topps Baseball$4 ungraded

Sam Esposito #425 1958 Topps Baseball$3 ungraded

Jim Marshall #441 1958 Topps Baseball$3 ungraded

Gene Conley #431 1958 Topps Baseball$3 ungraded

Chuck Essegian #460 1958 Topps Baseball$3 ungraded

Gene Fodge #449 1958 Topps Baseball$3 ungraded

Harvey Kuenn #434 1958 Topps Baseball$3 ungraded

Danny Kravitz #444 1958 Topps Baseball$3 ungraded

Ed Roebuck #435 1958 Topps Baseball$3 ungraded

Joe Taylor #451 1958 Topps Baseball$3 ungraded

Ron Blackburn #459 1958 Topps Baseball$2 ungraded

Bobby Thomson #430 1958 Topps Baseball$4 ungraded

Tom Qualters #453 1958 Topps Baseball$2 ungraded

Ray Narleski #439 1958 Topps Baseball$2 ungraded

Norm Zauchin #422 1958 Topps Baseball$3 ungraded

Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.