1958 Topps Baseball resale values

540 1958 Topps Baseball priced on real sold comps, ranging from $1 to $4,440. See what each is worth — loose or complete — before you buy or sell.

Updated August 2026 · prices refresh as new sales close.

Filtered: Topps · 540 items · clear ×

Contest Card [All Star Game] 1958 Topps Baseball$4 used

Ted Lepcio #29 1958 Topps Baseball$3 used

George Crowe #12 1958 Topps Baseball$3 used

Felix Mantilla #17 1958 Topps Baseball$5 used

Billy Hoeft [Yellow Red Triangle] #13 1958 Topps Baseball$12 used

Charley Neal #16 1958 Topps Baseball$3 used

Jim Lemon #15 1958 Topps Baseball$3 used

Hank Bauer #9 1958 Topps Baseball$7 used

Tex Clevenger #31 1958 Topps Baseball$3 used

New York Giants #19 1958 Topps Baseball$5 used

Hobie Landrith #24 1958 Topps Baseball$4 used

Frank Sullivan #18 1958 Topps Baseball$3 used

Bud Freeman #27 1958 Topps Baseball$3 used

George Zuverink #6 1958 Topps Baseball$3 used

Curt Barclay #21 1958 Topps Baseball$2 used

Hobie Landrith [White Name] #24 1958 Topps Baseball$2 used

Don Larsen #161 1958 Topps Baseball$7 used

Rocky Colavito #368 1958 Topps Baseball$7 used

Marv Throneberry #175 1958 Topps Baseball$7 used

Tom Acker #149 1958 Topps Baseball$3 used

Complete Set 1958 Topps Baseball$2532 used

Don Newcombe #340 1958 Topps Baseball$7 used

Ted Kluszewski #178 1958 Topps Baseball$5 used

Mike Baxes #302 1958 Topps Baseball$3 used

Sport Magazine All-Star Managers [All Star] #475 1958 Topps Baseball$4 used

Sherm Lollar [All Star] #491 1958 Topps Baseball$3 used

Whitey Herzog #438 1958 Topps Baseball$4 used

Ryne Duren #296 1958 Topps Baseball$5 used

Del Ennis [Yellow] #60 1958 Topps Baseball$8 used

Elston Howard #275 1958 Topps Baseball$6 used

Jim Gilliam #215 1958 Topps Baseball$6 used

Al Dark #125 1958 Topps Baseball$3 used

Milt Pappas #457 1958 Topps Baseball$3 used

Johnny Temple [All Star] #478 1958 Topps Baseball$2 used

Don Bessent #401 1958 Topps Baseball$3 used

Herb Score [All Star] #495 1958 Topps Baseball$3 used

Red Schoendienst #190 1958 Topps Baseball$6 used

Pancho Herrera [Herrer] #433 1958 Topps Baseball$4440 used

Jim Rivera [Yellow] #11 1958 Topps Baseball$20 used

Harvey Haddix #118 1958 Topps Baseball$5 used

Bill Skowron [All Star] #477 1958 Topps Baseball$6 used

Robin Roberts #90 1958 Topps Baseball$9 used

Johnny Kucks #87 1958 Topps Baseball$4 used

Felt Emblems Insert 1958 Topps Baseball$29 used

Jim Rivera [White] #11 1958 Topps Baseball$2 used

Pancho Herrera #433 1958 Topps Baseball$5 used

Tony Kubek #393 1958 Topps Baseball$6 used

Carl Furillo #417 1958 Topps Baseball$6 used

Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.