$5 American Gold Eagle resale values
81 $5 American Gold Eagle priced on real sold comps, ranging from $283 to $1,396. See what each is worth — loose or complete — before you buy or sell.
Updated August 2026 · prices refresh as new sales close.
2004 W [PROOF] $5 American Gold Eagle$480 ungraded
2006 $5 American Gold Eagle$498 ungraded
2006 W [PROOF] $5 American Gold Eagle$440 ungraded
1993 $5 American Gold Eagle$425 ungraded
1994 $5 American Gold Eagle$425 ungraded
1994 W [PROOF] $5 American Gold Eagle$419 ungraded
1995 W [PROOF] $5 American Gold Eagle$283 ungradednone sold in 29d · 20 listed
2002 $5 American Gold Eagle$403 ungraded
2003 W [PROOF] $5 American Gold Eagle$405 ungraded
2005 W [PROOF] $5 American Gold Eagle$360 ungraded
1992 $5 American Gold Eagle$503 ungraded
1993 P [PROOF] $5 American Gold Eagle$364 ungraded
1995 $5 American Gold Eagle$441 ungraded
1997 W [PROOF] $5 American Gold Eagle$414 ungraded
1998 $5 American Gold Eagle$500 ungraded
1999 $5 American Gold Eagle$413 ungraded
1999 W [PROOF] $5 American Gold Eagle$487 ungraded
2001 W [PROOF] $5 American Gold Eagle$351 ungraded
2000 W [PROOF] $5 American Gold Eagle$432 ungraded
2003 $5 American Gold Eagle$290 ungradednone sold in 29d · 6 listed
2002 W [PROOF] $5 American Gold Eagle$520 ungraded
2005 $5 American Gold Eagle$500 ungraded
2006 W [BURNISHED] $5 American Gold Eagle
1988 P [PROOF] $5 American Gold Eagle$533 ungraded
1987 $5 American Gold Eagle$472 ungraded
1990 $5 American Gold Eagle$478 ungraded
1989 $5 American Gold Eagle$458 ungraded
1991 P [PROOF] $5 American Gold Eagle$449 ungraded
1986 $5 American Gold Eagle$372 ungraded
1988 $5 American Gold Eagle$381 ungraded
1990 P [PROOF] $5 American Gold Eagle$432 ungraded
1989 P [PROOF] $5 American Gold Eagle$328 ungraded
1991 $5 American Gold Eagle$332 ungraded
Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.
Page 2 of 2